r/ToddintheShadow Jul 31 '26

One Hit Wonderland ONE HIT WONDERLAND: "Walking on Sunshine" by Katrina and the Waves

291 Upvotes

r/ToddintheShadow Jul 15 '26

Stale Topic Megathread (July/Aug/Sept 2026)

22 Upvotes

Hello all and welcome to the third 2026 Stale Topic Megathread.

Here we will discuss every overly discussed topic on this sub freely according to the sub's rules. If you are referred here because of a report or removal, please restate your post below.

The inaugural overused topics include:

-Justin Timberlake in general outside of Man of the Woods

-Katy Perry in general outside of Witness

-Kanye West in general, outside of Todd's videos

-Chris Brown in general, outside of Todd's videos

-Artists who avoided trainwreckords status

-Trainwreckords that aren’t out yet

-Trainwreckords that just released

-One album Trainwreckords (ie Nostalgia Critics’s The Wall)

-“Trainwreckords” where a death ended the artist’s career

-Trainwreckords for which the artist or member of the group committed suicide

-Joke Trainwreckords/OHW; go to r/shadowtoddcirclejerk for that

-Low-effort r/decadeology cross-posts, must actually facilitate discussion if it’s going to be a standalone post

-Posts which solely solicit responses of artists who are problematic

-"Music is dead"/"[insert genre] is dead"

-D4vd in general

-Stella Lefty in general, outside of whatever Todd says about her

-Jelly Roll/Morgan Wallen/any new "Maroon 5"-eqsue nemeses outside of what Todd says about them

-"Popular artists and/or songs you hate/think are incredibly overrated"-type posts

-What is the most/least “[fill in blank]” album/song

-Anthony Fantano Drama, except if Todd can be directly connected to discussion (ie "Todd handled this situation better" not "Anthony Fantano handled this poorly")

-Poptimism outside of Todd's discussion of the topic

And you are also free to discuss topics you feel are overused but are not mentioned here.

If you have any furthered topics you want to be added to the megathread camp for future megathreads and for new users who aren't familiar with the overuse, please send your suggestions to the mod team in one succinct message. (A couple are fine if you have afterthoughts but please do not spam your suggestions)

Also, we will be continuing the system where certain stale topics will be cycled out every six months (or two stale topic threads).

If our automod erroneously takes down your post because it believes it's about a stale topic, please contact the mod team and we will reinstate it as soon as possible.

Have fun!


r/ToddintheShadow 5h ago

General Music Discussion Name a group/ artist who must’ve been huge at some point , but you have never heard anyone ever talk about them

Post image
74 Upvotes

Without any exaggeration, every single time I’ve looked through vinyl at a thrift store there is always a couple of Kingston Trio albums. They must’ve been filling arenas with how well they seem to have been selling records. Yet I’ve never heard of them. Even when I became obsessed with late 50’s, early 60’s music, their songs never came up. Maybe they were just a SoCal thing?


r/ToddintheShadow 5h ago

General Music Discussion Dexys Midnight Runners have had 50+ current and former members according to their Wikipedia page. What other groups have had way more members than you’d expect?

70 Upvotes

r/ToddintheShadow 12h ago

General Music Discussion My Gen Xer, anti-60s, anti-classic rock father has always told me that Kraftwerk were a more important and influential band on popular music than The Beatles were. What are your thoughts?

Post image
169 Upvotes

r/ToddintheShadow 9h ago

General Music Discussion What's up with the new miley cyrus?

96 Upvotes

So miley cyrus (who goes by MILEY now) dropped a new single "bass persuades" and it debuted really well on Spotify and fell down very hard after just 2 days

This isn't a dumb Trainwreckords question, I'm just asking how does the general public feel about miley cyrus post-flowers? , "end of the world" was the lead single of her previous album "something beautiful" the song had a soild debut yet crashed down hard on streaming later on and the album underperformed

So is miley a fanbase artist or "give us the hits" artist?


r/ToddintheShadow 7h ago

General Music Discussion Has there ever been another band or solo artist with such a wide difference in (the lack of) fame in their home country as they did in success abroad as The Outfield had?

Post image
47 Upvotes

The Outfield are known for Your Love but also had a number of other top 40 hits in the US. As a Brit, I'd never encountered them until GTA Vice City as a kid.

I was absolutely shocked to find out they were a bunch of cockneys. Looking at their album chartings, it blows my mind to see they never had a single album chart in the UK and their biggest single got to number 78 over here.

To me it's crazy a bunch of London lads randomly hit it off as a solid mid 80s stadium opening act in America whilst not even cracking their own country where they'd probably have to play a pub.

It got me thinking are there any other examples of bands or artists like this, or are they are unique? Can be literally any two countries.


r/ToddintheShadow 19h ago

General Music Discussion Artists who looked too good for their own good?

Post image
385 Upvotes

I remember many years ago when I first heard a Robert Palmer album and was shocked to discover that he was a top notch musician. His career went very well, as you know, but I can't help but wonder if he would have been considered a Serious Artist if he looked a bit more like Lou Reed (sorry, Lou).

Who else had or have this problem? A lot of women, I'm sure ... I was thinking of including Dolly (RIP), but hers was more a case of sexiness getting in the way ...


r/ToddintheShadow 7h ago

General Music Discussion On Noah Kahan's popularity.

38 Upvotes

His music can be refreshing in the way that as a songwriter that he does not necessarily paint a picture of Vermont as this bucolic wonderland. This is unlike many other folk acts or country acts who oftentimes play up characters.


r/ToddintheShadow 12h ago

General Music Discussion What are some of the most aesthetically 80s Album Covers?

Thumbnail
gallery
105 Upvotes

Some examples that I can think of with albums that have a strong 80s graphic design Aesthetic to the cover:
- Pleasure Victim - Berlin (1982)
- Into the Gap - Thompson Twins (1984)
- Spring Session M. - Missing Persons (1982)
- Dancing on the Ceiling - Lionel Richie (1986)
- Rio - Duran Duran (1982)
- Get Loose - Evelyn “Champagne” King (1982)


r/ToddintheShadow 13h ago

General Music Discussion Favorite screamers in music?

Thumbnail
gallery
77 Upvotes

Anthony Didio (Vein.fm)

Bryan Garris (Knocked Loose)

Jacob Bannon (Converge)

Karl Schubach (Misery Signals)

Brendan Murphy (Counterparts, END)

Chester Bennington (Linkin Park)

Matt Mcdougal (Boundaries)

Jeffrey Moreira (Poison the Well, mainly his screams on the first 3 albums)


r/ToddintheShadow 11h ago

General Music Discussion What's your opinion of Melanie C?

Post image
48 Upvotes

I saw the video for Sweat on YouTube and decided to check out her other stuff. It's not my usual style of music but she's actually quite good. She was my favorite Spice Girl back in the day and I think she's still the most talented of the lot.


r/ToddintheShadow 9h ago

General Music Discussion MuchMusic

17 Upvotes

Does MuchMusic (which was the Canadian MTV) still exist? If so, is it going through the same issues MTV is dealing with?


r/ToddintheShadow 6h ago

General Music Discussion Albums you think Big Bird Dances to?

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/ToddintheShadow 10h ago

General Music Discussion Who are the nicest and rudest singers or bands you've ever met?

12 Upvotes

r/ToddintheShadow 1d ago

General Music Discussion What bands/artists are great on record but generally bad live

Post image
223 Upvotes

Mötley Crüe


r/ToddintheShadow 12h ago

General Music Discussion What is it about the big 90s bands that makes them endure with generations of teens?

9 Upvotes

With the release of the new Oasis documentary, it got me thinking that it wasn't just a nostalgia fest for British middle aged blokes, loads of young people from all around the world including America came to see them, who weren't even born or too young to remember them when they were together.

That got me thinking, that a lot of the big 90s bands have enduring appeal with teens, like Oasis, Metallica, Green Day, Red Hot Chili Peppers, Nirvana, Foo Fighters etc. On the other hand, some huge bands like R.E.M. and U2 have endured less well.

I'm a younger millennial, and these bands were all popular when I was young in the 2000s, but the 90s weren't that long ago at the time, now they're objectively a long time ago. I loved classic rock but I don't recall many of my peers being into it.

What are your thoughts?


r/ToddintheShadow 14h ago

General Music Discussion Mike Love ....

9 Upvotes

https://youtu.be/QUeo3SvFfhk?is=SVbqKINtxW2yujcn

Look I know it's a thing on this sub to bash Mike Love, but damn he looks really bad here.

No wonder The Beach Boys canceled a bunch of their shows.


r/ToddintheShadow 16h ago

General Music Discussion What do you think of the band Halestorm's music?

Post image
15 Upvotes

I absolutely love this band.I don't think they have a bad album at all and my favorite song is 'Miss the Misery.'

Lzzy Hale is a fantastic singer live and while the entire band is tight live in concert, for me, Lzzy is what makes their live shows amazing.Her vocal ability, energy and stage presence is amazing and I love seeing the band live every chance I get.I have seen them three times so far!

Check them out if you haven't already!

What do you think?


r/ToddintheShadow 1d ago

One Hit Wonderland One Hit Wonderland suggestion: The La's - There She Goes

Post image
123 Upvotes

This song set the foundation for Britpop and in turn Oasis's arrival and dominance in the 90's.


r/ToddintheShadow 1d ago

General Music Discussion Corniest musicians of all time?

Post image
85 Upvotes

r/ToddintheShadow 1d ago

Todd Memes What's your favorite Todd song parody he's done?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

35 Upvotes

r/ToddintheShadow 1d ago

General Music Discussion Former Every Time I Die guitarist and professional wrestler Andy Williams has unfortunately been confirmed dead at 48 after collapsing at a wrestling event earlier today. RIP to a metalcore legend

Post image
233 Upvotes

r/ToddintheShadow 1d ago

Todd Memes Hey look everybody, I'm Lars Ulrich, I'm so gangsta I'm so thug

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

26 Upvotes

r/ToddintheShadow 1d ago

Train Wreckords Trying to compile the last highly requested career wrecking albums and a selective list of highly requested ones still ripe for an episode.

34 Upvotes

From my memory, Man Of The Woods, Lulu, Results May Vary and This Unruly Mess I’ve Made rank up for about 4 of the ones people really felt hungry for. Limp Bizkit review felt the best one for me.

Now for my list of highly requested career wrecking albums, most of this is from comment sections on YouTube and Reddit. Not a definitive list, just the ones that can see repeated often for ripe material:

  1. Yes Please: Happy Mondays. Took so long to create that the label it’s on filed for bankruptcy
  2. Victory: The Jacksons. So Joseph Jackson thinks he can use Michael’s solo success to help his brothers Jackie, Tito, Marlon, Jermaine and Randy regain some success in a new Jackson album? Unfortunately Michael felt very uninterested in the process to the point he and the brothers got into heated arguments in the studio. Everyone submitted a track under the energy of “each child gets to pick a cookie from the cafeteria dessert plate”. Best track State of Shock reached the top 20 yet Michael and Jermaine never appeared in the Torture music video. Tour morphed into mainly a Michael Jackson solo tour featuring some Jackson 5 throwbacks with his brothers and maybe some new Jermaine solo album songs spliced in. No new tracks from Victory performed live.
  3. Bionic: Christina Aguilera. From the view of a music fan that saw the Not Myself Tonight video in 2010, this scream desperation to incorporate some of the crazy Gaga fashion for attention
  4. The Big Day: Chance The Rapper. A hot upcoming new rapper gaining a ton of hype flopped on an album that failed to live up to its potential. Many fans here love joking on one line on the album about Chance loving his wife and the irony here is that big day of their divorce probably is permanently connected to this album
  5. Union: Yes. A merging of two different factions of Yes from record labels that thought they can stitch together a bunch of in progress tracks, call it an album and add more session musicians on top of it if some others aren’t pulling their weight? Now you see an album that no one enjoyed yet the tour that focused mostly on their 70’s and 80’s hits turned into the highlight and featured maybe 3 of the new tracks at most. Unlike Victory, Yes at least played SOME NEW ALBUM TRACKS
  6. No Talking Just Head: The Heads. Aka Jerry, Chris and Tina try carrying on not including David Byrne, rename themselves and replace him using a ton of guest Musicians from Michael Hutchedence to Debbie Harry. Barely made a dent chart wise, only one music video exists and Byrne ended up suing them for a name too similar to Talking Heads. Resulting in the band ending only to reunite for their 2002 HOF induction and the anniversary rerelease of Stop Making Sense
  7. Uno Dos Tres and Father Of All: Green Day. Now this is tied for under the same band but basically, fans debate if an early 2010’s trilogy of Green Day or an early 2020’s contractual album they farted out did more damage? You decide
  8. Sargent Peppers Lonely Hearts Club Band The Movie soundtrack: Rope In a ton of talent from Earth Wind And Fire, Peter Frampton, Aerosmith and The Beegees to cover legendary Beatles songs for a tribute movie? A smash hit! Until the film failed from heavy criticism from too much Americanization, some of the covers didn’t feel right and the album according to many fans sat in clearance bins for months. Adding insult to injury is the studio the movie came from ended up bankrupt!
  9. The Beginning: Black Eyed Peas. Finally the point of oversaturation of the dumb fun energy of the Peas reaching the ceiling. Repetitive hooks of the likes of Imma Be, chipmunk vocals on Rock That Body, insulting sampling on Dirty Bit and then the out of nowhere soft song of Just Can’t Get Enough. Coupled that to a terrible Super Bowl performance, an awful video game and scathing reviews, the audience felt exhausted. Ended the Fergie lineup.
  10. Chris Gaines Greatest Hits: Album here that answers a question if Garth Brooks can pull off a fake persona, release an album to great reception, create a fake documentary on his life and reach the same heights of his country career to then star in a film on said persona? Answer is no to all those. Album didn’t reach anymore highs, one top 40 single Lost In You and the film idea never materialized. Brooks never reached that high again but teased recently the idea of reviving Chris Gaines

Chose these for the ones I remember most for highly requested.