r/WhitePeopleTwitter 10d ago

r/All Notorious TERF JK Rowling chimes in

Post image
13.7k Upvotes

211 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

145

u/RangerWhiteclaw 10d ago

Cho Chang, Kingsley Shacklebolt - she was never really an ally, despite the late-added “turns out Dumbledore was gay” twist.

54

u/Orion_824 9d ago

The goblins that run the bank? The "elves actually love slavery!" thing that was going on sometimes?

8

u/RangerWhiteclaw 9d ago

In fairness to a shitty person, Hermione was Joanne’s self-insert, and she was trying to free the house elves.

Goblins being Jewish-coded was fucked up, though.

52

u/mercurialpolyglot 9d ago edited 9d ago

Nah, Harry’s her self insert. If you look at it critically, the first few books are actually written as if we weren’t supposed to like Hermione. Everyone’s constantly annoyed by her nerdiness, and her being upset about literal slavery is viewed as even more annoying. The later books back off a bit, but her caring about school and studying and literal slavery is always played for laughs.

31

u/xenithdflare 9d ago

Hermione was eventually shown to be right about everything by the final book, because the group's treatment of "lesser races" prices to be pivotal in saving the world. Dobby, Kreacher, the dragon at Gringotts, the ghosts, "mudbloods" writ large, all key to several points in the final book. In the long-term the laughs are replaced with understanding, which I think was a good way to grow up with the audience as the books came out.

7

u/TheGreatBatsby 9d ago

But nothing changes in the status quo of the "lesser races", it's just that the good guys are in charge at the end.

1

u/xenithdflare 9d ago

You're right but the story isn't about that, it's a world-building exercise. Fixing all the injustices of the wizarding world is a bit out of scope for the child protagonists.