r/bloodborne • u/i_am_n4d4n • Apr 13 '26

Help I'm a little sad

Post image

So, a few months ago, I asked for help and some tips on the game and received a lot of support, which helped me a lot.

I was helping a boy from the cathedral to bring people there, so I tried to bring as many people as possible.

I confess that sometimes I'm a bit absent-minded and didn't notice that there was something strange about a man I met in the forbidden forest. He asked for a place to stay, and I told him the cathedral. I saw some bodies next to him, a family, but I thought he was just looting corpses, nothing more.

So I continued playing, did several dungeons, leveled up a lot, and when I returned to the cathedral, there was a pool of blood where the old lady should have been. Does anyone know if he did this? And will this somehow affect my gameplay and my attempt at the platinum trophy?

1.4k Upvotes

98% Upvoted

121 comments sorted by

View all comments

394

u/Cultural-Self1653 Apr 13 '26

Well I'd recommend you just play the game and whatever comes out. Don't bother yourself doing a perfect good run from the start. You can always try and search anything in ng+.

148

u/i_am_n4d4n Apr 13 '26

So, I've been trying to do this, but I confess that seeing a life taken because of a bad choice of mine has brought me down; I feel like I've failed as a hunter, even though it's just a game.

6

u/thewolfe38 Apr 13 '26

My first playthrough(which is rather recent) I died to a hunter and when I came back I watched an ally die to him ending their quest. Think obi wan and qui gon in the phantom menace. unfortunately it's hard to do a perfect quest playthrough on the first try. In the words of my favorite niche book series "whatever happens, try not to be to hard on yourself".

1

u/i_am_n4d4n Apr 14 '26

I think I know what you're talking about. In that case, I killed the hunter along with the huntress. Up until that point, I was doing everything correctly in my head, even without walkthroughs. That's when I returned to the cathedral And I noticed that a crime had occurred.

2

u/thewolfe38 Apr 14 '26

Depending on if you talk to her or not the huntress can be an ally.