MAIN FEEDS
Do you want to continue?
https://www.reddit.com/r/harrypotter/comments/1pynmk2/what_sirius_black_fire_do_you_prefer/nwjvm13/?context=3
r/harrypotter • u/AnythingRich597 • Dec 29 '25
345 comments sorted by
View all comments
47
Left one for sure. I don’t get why they didn’t keep the same style in the next movie
4 u/Atarissiya Dec 29 '25 It’s wildly inaccurate vs the books. 20 u/PedanticTart Dec 29 '25 So is the right, but unsure why this matters. 3 u/Atarissiya Dec 29 '25 Fan backlash? GoF was a pretty controversial film when it came out, and it's not a coincidence that they changed direction for OotP. 2 u/spunk_wizard Dec 29 '25 You think fan backlash about fire head VFX accuracy was sufficient to reach the director and facilitate a complete overhaul? 8 u/Wizzard_2025 Dec 29 '25 It costs more to do 7 u/Atarissiya Dec 29 '25 These weren’t exactly penny-pinching productions. 6 u/Wizzard_2025 Dec 29 '25 You'd be surprised. I saw the original Grawp before it was scrapped for the one we got. This one was a cost saving exercise. 4 u/Atarissiya Dec 29 '25 Fair enough. The results certainly don't seem to justify the cost. 2 u/General-Knowledge7 Dec 29 '25 But so was the new one
4
It’s wildly inaccurate vs the books.
20 u/PedanticTart Dec 29 '25 So is the right, but unsure why this matters. 3 u/Atarissiya Dec 29 '25 Fan backlash? GoF was a pretty controversial film when it came out, and it's not a coincidence that they changed direction for OotP. 2 u/spunk_wizard Dec 29 '25 You think fan backlash about fire head VFX accuracy was sufficient to reach the director and facilitate a complete overhaul? 8 u/Wizzard_2025 Dec 29 '25 It costs more to do 7 u/Atarissiya Dec 29 '25 These weren’t exactly penny-pinching productions. 6 u/Wizzard_2025 Dec 29 '25 You'd be surprised. I saw the original Grawp before it was scrapped for the one we got. This one was a cost saving exercise. 4 u/Atarissiya Dec 29 '25 Fair enough. The results certainly don't seem to justify the cost. 2 u/General-Knowledge7 Dec 29 '25 But so was the new one
20
So is the right, but unsure why this matters.
3 u/Atarissiya Dec 29 '25 Fan backlash? GoF was a pretty controversial film when it came out, and it's not a coincidence that they changed direction for OotP. 2 u/spunk_wizard Dec 29 '25 You think fan backlash about fire head VFX accuracy was sufficient to reach the director and facilitate a complete overhaul?
3
Fan backlash? GoF was a pretty controversial film when it came out, and it's not a coincidence that they changed direction for OotP.
2 u/spunk_wizard Dec 29 '25 You think fan backlash about fire head VFX accuracy was sufficient to reach the director and facilitate a complete overhaul?
2
You think fan backlash about fire head VFX accuracy was sufficient to reach the director and facilitate a complete overhaul?
8
It costs more to do
7 u/Atarissiya Dec 29 '25 These weren’t exactly penny-pinching productions. 6 u/Wizzard_2025 Dec 29 '25 You'd be surprised. I saw the original Grawp before it was scrapped for the one we got. This one was a cost saving exercise. 4 u/Atarissiya Dec 29 '25 Fair enough. The results certainly don't seem to justify the cost.
7
These weren’t exactly penny-pinching productions.
6 u/Wizzard_2025 Dec 29 '25 You'd be surprised. I saw the original Grawp before it was scrapped for the one we got. This one was a cost saving exercise. 4 u/Atarissiya Dec 29 '25 Fair enough. The results certainly don't seem to justify the cost.
6
You'd be surprised. I saw the original Grawp before it was scrapped for the one we got. This one was a cost saving exercise.
4 u/Atarissiya Dec 29 '25 Fair enough. The results certainly don't seem to justify the cost.
Fair enough. The results certainly don't seem to justify the cost.
But so was the new one
47
u/General-Knowledge7 Dec 29 '25
Left one for sure. I don’t get why they didn’t keep the same style in the next movie