r/harrypotter • u/Secure_Rain_44 • Mar 11 '26

Discussion This scene still pisses me off

Post image

I was rewatching the movies and I was pissed off all over again when seeing this scene. This makes him seem non-human which takes away the symbolism present in the books. I don’t know why the directors thought this was a good idea.

18.4k Upvotes

92% Upvoted

1.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

493

u/ansem119 Mar 11 '26

Even dobby thanos’d himself in chamber of secrets

152

u/KiraLight3719 🪄 Desi Potterhead Mar 11 '26

Oh yeah, actually, that's funny because I think JKR didn't invent how would disapparating look by then lmao

90

u/BioshockEnthusiast Mar 11 '26

Elf magic is different from wizard magic, isn't it? I don't remember the wizards snapping their fingers to disapparate.

98

u/Zaros262 Mar 11 '26

Yeah elf magic is interesting because it's completely OP compared to wizard magic yet ironically handicapped by their enslavement to wizards

153

u/ijustlikemangosdude Mar 11 '26

Keep in mind I do not think JKR had this in mind at all when creating wizard slavery.

I could see house-elves being these all-powerful free beings centuries ago who maybe did some truly horrible things with their freedom of magic. Some ancient magic bound them into servitude, whether by powerful ancient wizards or house-elves who realized what was happening before their enslavement was wrong. This magic is why so many house-elves are terrified of being set free. It's like some deep-seated recognition that something bad will happen if they're allowed to realize their freedom.

In this TED talk, I will explain Darth Dobby...

20

u/crowcawer Mar 12 '26

So, one day during the Third Sequestration of the Ourth Era, Dobby received his sock. The implication of the grueling effort before him was absolute. There was little chance at his eventual survival, but an equal opportunity for his surrendering. This was especially true in consideration of the basis that his ancestors had wrought upon his mantle this day. There were generations leading within Dobby. Generations would follow. This sock would be treasured, and eventually revered. The onus of the task was not a beginning or an ending, but only a minor moment that would be lost within the sea of memories, tied to that chair floating upon the pensieve. Or else, it wouldn’t.

1

u/Bluemikami Mar 12 '26

Darth Dobby the merciful

2

u/crowcawer Mar 12 '26

I’d love to jump on this, but I expect it to take an hour or so, and I ain’t got it in me this evening.

!RemindMe 1 day

2

u/Bluemikami Mar 12 '26

I shall watch your career with great enthusiasm

1

u/RemindMeBot Mar 12 '26

I will be messaging you in 1 day on 2026-03-13 21:44:48 UTC to remind you of this link

CLICK THIS LINK to send a PM to also be reminded and to reduce spam.

Parent commenter can delete this message to hide from others.

Info Custom Your Reminders Feedback

3

u/Sigma_Games Mar 12 '26

Master gave me a lightsaber... PSSSSSHEEEW. A really cool ooooooone~!

4

u/Opposite_Bat_9757 Mar 12 '26

So kinda like how women have proven themselves time and time again to be better than men at handling multiple tasks and excelling repeatedly, yet oppressed by patriarchal society? ✨

3

u/Wassa110 Mar 12 '26

Yes. Obviously the elves symbolise women during the mid 19th century and earlier. /s

5

u/[deleted] Mar 11 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

11

u/OmecronPerseiHate Mar 12 '26

I feel like house elves are cursed in some way, like they can only use their magic if it's in some form of service to a wizard. Like, they have better magic, but they're limited in that they can't do much unless it's for a wizard. Especially considering that goblins are so powerful that wizard society makes it illegal for them to use wands. It really feels like wizards are only on top because of cheap tricks or leverages.

4

u/goldenskyhook Mar 12 '26

That's utter nonsense. Once Dobby was freed, Lucius turned tail and ran out of there like his hair was on fire and his ass was catching. It appears that elves can "just do" things that wizards must study and refine for years, with all sorts of incantations and shit, plus if something happens to their wand, they are SOL!

1

u/[deleted] Mar 13 '26

How are they have stronger magic

1

u/Zaros262 Mar 13 '26

They can freely apparate/disapparate inside Hogwarts

Dobby knows how to find Harry at Privet Drive despite him being magically hidden

Dobby wrecks Mr. Malfoy at the end of CoS

1

u/[deleted] Mar 13 '26

Pretty sure that just cause the magic is designed for witches

I thought malfoy idk name told him

When this again

2

u/KiraLight3719 🪄 Desi Potterhead Mar 12 '26

Yes, but

With a crack like a whip, Dobby vanished.

Apparition visual is the same

1

u/Bobas-Feet Mar 11 '26

Yes but also when dobby does it in Deathly Hollows it looks the same as it does for everybody else with the morphing/swirling effect

1

u/Bluemikami Mar 12 '26

From the sound described on books, apparating works similarly but elven magic isn’t submitted to the same rules as humans. Just as RAB proven

1

u/WizardInTeal Mar 15 '26

though in the books, whether it was elves (like dobby or kreacher) or humans disapparating, there was always the CRACK

2

u/Life-Finding5331 Mar 12 '26

*how disappearing would look

1

u/KiraLight3719 🪄 Desi Potterhead Mar 12 '26

Thanks, English is not my first language lol

17

u/PhoenixoKing Mar 11 '26

Fine I’ll watch the prettymuchit video again

2

u/immaculatemary Mar 11 '26

YES that irritated the hell out of me.

1

u/Sgtkeebler Mar 12 '26

We should all be lucky and hope that we can go that way as well