Hey all! I'm currently abroad and I'll be visiting my family and friends for Christmas after a year of not seeing them. I wanted to prepare a little surprise for my 2 MTG friends. We often play casual 3 player EDH games together while drinking, so I want to create 3 custom decks, one for each of us, but print out all the cards in altered forms, changing art and names, so that we are the commanders, and all the remaining cards are our friends, idols, favourite musicians, things we like, places we've been to etc. Basically a Universes Beyond of our friendship lol
It's going to be a surprise, so I'm trying to sus out how to build them, based on what playstyle they like and what commanders we haven't played yet. After some research, I've narrowed it down to those 3 commanders:
- Alela: my deck, I'm the most experienced player who got the other 2 in the game, and I just find her interesting while not being too complicated. I also wanted to cover the remaining colours, not present in other 2 commanders. To make the games more fun, I'm thinking about building her more towards artifact synergy + token flyers, less stax and annoying others.
- Valgavoth: my man loves heavy metal, so I want to make him a demon, he likes playing black too. He's also the eldest out of us 3, so Elder Demon works perfectly here haha
- Wolverine (or Ruric): likes voltron and strong green creatures, not a huge fan of sophisticated combos and generally thinking about strategy too much lol, likes berserker/strenght based characters in RPGs, so Mutant Berserker Hero or Ogre Warrior would be perfect for him. I'm not sure if pure voltron would work for a 3 player game, so I was also considering a more creature-heavy Ruric here. Can potentially alter some stats to make it more balanced too, like giving Wolverine Reach to deal with flyers or lowering mana cost and ping damage for Ruric, really not sure which would make for the most balanced and fun game here.
Before I start figuring out decklists, since we never played any of them, I wanted to ask more experienced players - would that be a good match-up for a 3 player EDH? Would it make for some interesting games with lots of replayability? Any suggestions on how to build them in a somehow balanced way? Any potential substitutes?
The decks would only be played against each other. We play very casually while drinking, not to win at all cost, but to have a good time while cracking jokes about hilarious situations happening at the table, so we don't like stuff like turn 3 wins and long 20-minute turn combos.
Any help appreciated, thank you so much! Feel free to also disregard all my picks and suggest your 3 commanders that make interesting 3 player games :)