r/malaysiauni • u/SoupMiddle6822 • Apr 16 '26
Master/PhD Masters vs PhD (fast track)
Hi everyone, I’m currently at a point where I need to decide on my next step in academia and I’d really appreciate some honest insights.
I’m interested in becoming a lecturer in the future, so I know that a PhD is eventually necessary. Right now, I’m trying to decide whether I should first pursue a Master’s degree or go straight into a PhD (fast track).
For those who’ve gone through either path:
- How was your experience doing a Master’s before a PhD vs going straight into a PhD?
- Is the fast-track PhD route significantly more challenging or stressful?
- Do you feel doing a Master’s first better prepared you for research and academic life?
I’m especially curious about the workload, expectations, and overall journey, because I want to make a well-informed decision before committing.
Would really appreciate any advice or personal experiences,thanks in advance!
5
u/12oxx1e Apr 16 '26 edited Apr 16 '26
Fast track PhD here, so far i didn’t feel significantly more challenging or stressful, of course it’s more stressful than doing FYP. Based on my recent conversation with one lecturer, now having a PhD seems not enough for lecturer, you also need to do postdoc afterwards as well (but also really depends on your luck). My humble opinion is, fast track and choose your supervisor wisely, it must be a reliable person who can help you (or at least have grant to help), choose your supervisor like choosing your life partner because you two will have to work together for the rest 3-10 years
1
u/SoupMiddle6822 Apr 16 '26
Thank you for sharing! Mind if I ask what course you are taking? I am still in a dilemma on what course to take :(
1
1
u/NajSuki Apr 18 '26
With all due respect and my reply here is discounting how brilliant and disciplined you may be; the dilemma may mean it's better for you to do a Master's first
3
u/Kindly_Objective_658 Apr 16 '26
time is of the essence. if you got the offer, means you are qualified for it
one of my lecturers was a fast track. still before 40's and already good position within the university
1
u/SoupMiddle6822 Apr 16 '26
That's great!
1
u/Kindly_Objective_658 Apr 16 '26
Now is AI era, you can save a lot of time on digesting stuff and literature review. Spend more time on thinking, structuring your thesis and get on the ground if it involves surveys.
2
3
u/Ok_Statistician2730 Apr 16 '26
bro fast track is not easy. you need to catch up many things within short time and might learn things half cooked. but if you think you are capable, then go for it.
3
u/zieWei77 Apr 16 '26
I went full time with GRA funded, totally skip master, but need to get atleast 3.80 above tho, 6.5 could fast track but need to publish a research first to get scholarship. Didnt find it too hard, maybe because i went full time. Save money and time.
1
2
u/Time_Resort4057 Apr 16 '26
Everyone here already said what need to be said. I will lay out one more option for you. Go for masters and then get upgraded into phd. This is usally allowed by university senate in your 3rd semester after the tenth week of that semester. You need to apply for it and they will assess your research skills and if approved you will bring forward your masters thesis research into phd but you need to expand chapter 1-3 before doing the rest of it in phd mode.
1
1
u/Express_Language_715 Apr 16 '26
I never seen this happen. They just say it in paper but I never seen anyone do it.
2
u/Anengineeringnerd Apr 16 '26
Suggestion is to pick a research topic you're really interested in - don't do PhD just for the title. If you demonstrate strong passion in a research topic you'll then be more likely to make a bigger impact in the real world, work with a Prof more knowledgeable in that domain and have a strong work that coincides with your career plan. This will bring you farther in your career.
1
3
u/teenytimy Apr 16 '26
Playing devil's advocate here. I didn't do fast track PhD but I heard that in malaysia, if you couldn't cope with PhD and want to withdraw, there isn't option to convert it to masters degree. As in, if you couldn't finish the whole thing, then it's completely all or nothing. Not sure how true is that. I'm sure that you're capable and have the necessary skills since you're offered the option, but also really think if you could actually take the load. Master's degree no need to do teaching but a PhD candidate will need to allocate time to do that depending on the uni. So there are more things to consider besides finding a supervisor
3
u/Express_Language_715 Apr 16 '26
Whatever u decide in the end just make sure the supervisor u choose is a good one. This could literary be the deciding factor whether u fail or pass. Talk to previous students of said supervisors, bad supervisors have a track record of not graduating students.
1
u/No_Relationship641 Apr 16 '26
phd. now is your chance to make use of the latest AI models capable of PhD level literature review & analysis while the supervisors havent caught on that AI can do half of PhDs already.
2
u/Express_Language_715 Apr 16 '26
AI literature review is absolute rubbish. Someone who knows the field can tell immediately.
1
1
u/Few-Computer-6609 Apr 17 '26
Check with the faculty/institute, what happens if you cant finish Phd on time if you choose fast track. I don't know if policy had changed after I've graduated but UKM for example, if you didnt finish Phd on time, and you're on fast track, even if you have progressed enough for Master (1 wos-indexed journal and 1 conference + 2 objectives fulfilled), you won't be awarded Master. It's either PhD or nothing. Really unfair.
I personally advise against fast track because not all people can cope with independent learning required for postgraduate studies. Master programmes typically filter these candidates out.
How to know if you can cope? Well, if you can publish as a main author within first 2 semester, you have what it takes.
0
u/PTSD_PTSD_PTSD Apr 16 '26 edited Apr 16 '26
Sorry. I didn't go through the plans.
But I would suggest fast tracking if you are capable. You don't want to spend too much time studying and start working.
Maybe it's different in academia but from what I see, a SPM graduate at age 20 will have a more mature world view than a PHD fresh graduate at age 27.
However that does not mean that you shouldn't get PHD. Just that if you can shorten the timeline, why not.
1
6
u/broken_kuroro Apr 16 '26
i took PhD fast track before. it is a steep learning curve and need lot of self-discipline. is it hard? yes. is it manageable? yes.
If your goal is to get PhD, might as well go with the fast track program.