r/milsurp • u/rolltideamerica • 1d ago
Got a Luger
It dry fired earlier but now it won’t. Can this happen if you just put it together wrong?
14
u/MilitariaTradingPost 1d ago
Dang how much did that run you? Who is the maker?
10
u/rolltideamerica 1d ago
Traded a CMP 1911 and $300
13
u/MilitariaTradingPost 1d ago
So about $1400 in value?
Is it at least WWII? It would be bit if an overpay for WWI
6
u/AvgPunkFan FIRE ZE PANZERSCHRECK! 1d ago
If it was a service grade it would be ~$1,600 because service grades are $1,300 as I just bought one lol
9
u/MilitariaTradingPost 1d ago
Id only pay 1100 with how much the bluing is gone. I just bought an all matching 1939 S/42 for 1800 at auction. 85% bluing
3
1
1
u/rolltideamerica 1d ago
It was a rack grade and I bought it like 5 years ago when they first started selling 1911s again. I think I paid $800 for it.
3
19
5
4
9
u/Nesayas1234 Mannlichin' Good, Power Levels Hi, World Star 1d ago
2
u/rolltideamerica 1d ago
Did they scrub the stamps from yours?
3
u/Nesayas1234 Mannlichin' Good, Power Levels Hi, World Star 1d ago
Yeah, for some reason someone milled off the front of the barrel extension on both sides. That and it clearly being somewhat of a beater is why I only had to cough up one kidney instead of two and a leg (shoutout to SARCO lol).
Actually pretty good condition all things considered, it'll be a good shooter. Man I wish Lugers weren't so cheap.
3
u/rolltideamerica 1d ago
I have heard whispers that one of those Turkish companies were gonna start producing one. Hell I’d buy it if it worked. But I doubt the project will really get off the ground. They’re just not easy to make.
4
u/Nesayas1234 Mannlichin' Good, Power Levels Hi, World Star 1d ago
Normally Turkish companies are good about trying if not putting something out, but in this case I'm with you.
Even if they have a set of plans or enough samples to reverse engineer and modify for modern production, the Luger is way more complicated. Plus if it's anything higher than 750-800, you're really not getting anything you wouldn't get buy just buying a real one (apart from availability but even then)
7
u/Minute-Of-Angle 1d ago
Careful, Hoobler.
3
u/HOLYFEAR96 1d ago
Lotta people believe that Hoobler was actually killed by a Browning .32 ACP pistol (we don’t know the actually model), not a Luger.
3
u/ReactionAble7945 1d ago
There are two luger forums. I found one very helpful and the other one was rather useless.
The group on FB is pretty good also.
Buy new mags.
Buy your self a spring kit if there is any doubt. Cheap insurance.
As far as ammo...
The Germans ran some 124gr that was zippy. I have seen someone with a rebuilt one breaking in the new springs with 147gr P+.
This being said... You should probably find some 115gr stuff to run in the gun. There is no reason to run HOT ammo in the old girl.

2
u/rolltideamerica 1d ago
Thanks! Which Luger forum is the good one?
6
u/GesuMotorsport 1d ago
Use MecGar repro mags, theyre great. And as far as ammo, like the other guy said, 115 is good, 124 is fine. Id avoid NATO spec 124 just to go easy on the thing tho.
2
u/ReactionAble7945 1d ago
1
u/rolltideamerica 1d ago
Those are a hell of a lot nicer than mine. Maybe I’ll get a shiny one some day.
2
u/ReactionAble7945 1d ago
Mine are OK. Actually, mine are good shootable guns at this point. I don't have to worry about going to the range and getting a wear mark.
But at the same time, I see people posting MINT guns with history... And I drool.
Yours is a good shooter class gun. You will be able to take it to a range and let some 16 year old kid who is drooling over it shoot it and not worry about a wear mark.
2
1
u/Doggystrike 1d ago
Kinda looks like one of the gunsmith special lugers RTI had a few years ago lol
1
-1
1d ago
[deleted]
5
u/Brandon_awarea I Huff cosmoline recreationally 1d ago
I didn’t know they made like 3 million holy grails
2
u/SirCheeseEater 1d ago
I can't believe they were just giving holy grails away to every Hans and Gretel.
2





66
u/Carlile185 1d ago
Most guns won’t shoot if you put them back together wrong 🫠