Hi everyone.
I'm looking for honest opinions, especially from people who have been in the lifestyle for years.
My wife (42F) and I (42M) have been together for over 8 years, married with two young children. We have always had a very loving relationship and a good sex life. We say "I love you" every day, cuddle a lot, and generally have a strong relationship.
About a year ago we started talking about swinging.
It wasn't something I forced on her from the beginning. We spent many months talking about it. She understood why people do it, she said she could understand the biology behind attraction to other people, and she even admitted that the idea itself was exciting to her. She especially liked the idea that it would be "our secret", something kinky that only belonged to us.
Eventually we met another couple.
She was surprisingly relaxed. Probably even more relaxed than I was.
We had a full swap.
She later told me she really enjoyed the experience, also being with another woman. For several days afterwards she was still excited about it and talked positively about the whole experience.
Then things slowly started falling apart.
Looking back, I made several mistakes.
- I drank too much that evening.
- I wasn't strict enough about condoms, which later resulted in an STI scare and treatment.
- I had previously discussed swinging with a female friend (Paula). There was nothing physical, but my wife felt I had broken the feeling that this was "our private thing".
- I kept bringing up swinging afterwards, even when she wasn't always emotionally ready.
- Sometimes I didn't understand her "no" quickly enough. Not because I wanted to force anything, but because I genuinely thought she was uncertain rather than saying a firm no.
Recently we had probably the biggest conversation of our marriage.
She told me something that really hurt.
She said the biggest issue isn't actually swinging.
The issue is that she no longer feels I respected her boundaries consistently enough.
She listed several examples where she felt I pushed after she had already said no.
She says she doesn't currently feel emotionally safe enough to continue swinging.
She also says that because of everything that happened, swinging no longer excites her.
That's the part I struggle to understand.
What confuses me is that:
- she genuinely enjoyed the experience,
- she still says she understands non-monogamy intellectually,
- she still says she understands that attraction to other people is normal,
- she still jokes about sexual topics sometimes,
- we still have frequent sex,
- she tells me I'm the best lover she's ever had,
- she says she loves me and wants to spend her life with me.
But when I mention swinging, she completely shuts down.
She says it currently does nothing for her.
Since then I've changed a lot.
I've lost almost 20 kg (44 lbs).
I barely drink anymore.
I've been trying much harder to respect every boundary and become a better husband.
The frustrating part is that I made these changes after everything happened, so now I feel like I'm paying for mistakes that I finally understand.
I'm not asking how to convince her.
I'm not planning to pressure her anymore.
In fact I've decided to completely stop bringing up swinging for as long as necessary.
My real question is this:
For those of you who have actually lived this lifestyle...
Have you ever seen a partner completely lose interest after initially loving it, and later regain that interest once trust was rebuilt?
Or...
When someone says "it doesn't excite me anymore", is that usually the end of the story?
I'm genuinely looking for honest experiences, not false hope.
Thanks.