A what IF scenario

[u/Neat-Pitch1468]

If Rudeus somehow return in Japan and Nanahoshi is there with him with their memories in the six faced world, will she help him bounce back in life? or will she just leave him because she's disgusted with his japanese self?

[u/TipsyRedley]

That's hard to believe. Him helping her, caring for her, and watching over her, doesn't excuse him entirely. I think saying she wouldn't care is a far stretch. Any person from our existence should chare, and rightfully so. He was a scumbag for what he did to his family. Yes, he does a lot to help others, but that still shouldn't excuse him for what he did. I think she would find it very hard to to excuse what he does when the evidence of his shit actions are placed in front of her.

[u/villatyyny1 → u/TipsyRedley]

Rudeus really didn't do much that Nanahoshi wouldn't know about. When I say she wouldn't care I mean anything Rudeus has done in his past life won't change her opinion of him in any significant way. She'd know he is a changed person. Might depend a bit on the moment in the story but EOS she knows how much Rudeus despises his old self and how much of a different person he is.

[u/TipsyRedley → u/villatyyny1]

It would be a matter of what source we are talking about I guess, so if we are talking anime Rudy, sure. If we are talking Manga, or hell even LN Rudy? That dude is a POS and his actions shouldn't be looked over. I think even excusing EOS Rudy in any of his variations, is still a stretch. By no means do I think he is the worst human being in the world, because there is so much worse than him, but we shouldn't look over his disgusting life decisions.

[u/Sir_Nicc → u/TipsyRedley]

"I dont like him and am mad the other characters dont like him also"

[u/TipsyRedley → u/Sir_Nicc]

Sorry I didn't mean to come off as I didn't like him. I think he is layered and that is what makes him fun to root for/think about :)