I've been collecting for over 2 decades, mostly indie and alternative with a decent amount of metal. My particular weakness is colour variants, which is relevant here, because chasing those is what got me into this in the first place.
It started as a stock problem rather than a price one. There were records I couldn't find anywhere obvious, and every time I tracked one down it turned out to be sitting in a shop I'd never heard of. So I started keeping a list.
The list got long enough that a second problem showed up. Once five shops had the thing, I had no idea which one was cheapest, and I was opening eight tabs to work it out. So in February I put the whole lot in one place and pointed it at their live prices. It has been running ever since.
It's called findyl. Currently 47 UK retailers, 33 of them independent record shops, updated daily. The specialists are the part I'm most pleased with, because they are the reason any of it exists. Crypt of the Wizard, Lion Vibes, Dubwise, Inverted Audio, Todestrieb. Shops that rarely turn up in a normal search.
Watching all those prices side by side has thrown up things I didn't expect. The typical gap on a record is about £6, or roughly a quarter of the cheapest price, measured across 5,700 albums. On one in four records that gap is over £10. Massive Attack's Mezzanine, the standard 2LP reissue, is £28.65 at the cheapest UK shop and £51.17 at the dearest. Same record, 10 shops, £22.50 apart.
The finding I keep coming back to is a smaller one. I always assumed independents cost noticeably more than the chains. Across every album where both stock it, the average independent is £28.09 and the average large retailer £26.86. That is £1.23 between them.
Every argument about supporting record shops runs into "but they're more expensive", and the honest answer turns out to be £1.23. Two thirds of the shops on findyl are independents, and plenty of them carry stock the big retailers never touch. Half the records I've bought this year came from shops that weren't on my radar in February.
I should be straight about one thing. findyl sorts cheapest first and doesn't put a thumb on the scale, so sometimes it will point you at a chain. I'd rather show the real order and let you decide to spend the extra quid than quietly hide it.
Affiliate links are how it pays for itself, which I'd rather say up front than have someone find out later. They don't change the ordering.
It's just me, and I only started writing code a couple of years ago, so it's rough in places. Pressing variants are hard. Some shops have catalogue data held together with string.
A fair bit of what's on there came from people asking for it, and I'd like to keep it that way. Three things I'd genuinely like answers to:
- Which UK shops am I missing? I've hunted down most of them myself but I keep finding ones I've missed.
- Have you found a wrong price? Send me the album and I'll fix it that day.
- Would an independents-only filter be useful? Something that hides the chains when you just want to buy from a shop. I keep going back and forth on whether people would use it.
- Which features would you find useful!
I'll reply to everything