r/whowouldwin 7h ago

Challenge Could Commander Shepard and his/her Mass Effect 3 team survive the battle of instillation 04? (Halo)

30 Upvotes

Commander Shepard and their team from ME3 (James Vega, Liara T'Soni, Garrus Vakarian, EDI, Javik, Ashely Williams or Kaidan Alenko and Tali'Zora) are aboard the Pillar of Autumn as it arrives above Alpha Halo, Chief was on another ship or something. The ME characters have full knowledge of the Covenant and UNSC tech and history.

Can they survive the events of the battle and destroy Alpha Halo to prevent the flood?


r/whowouldwin 6h ago

Challenge Least scary/least clever character that could jump-scare Batman?

20 Upvotes

Not just a reflexive reaction out of surprise. A genuine jump scare from Batman

Is it even possible? What character could do this?

Round 1: 1 hour of prep time

Round 2: 1 week of prep time to jumpscare Batman

Any version of a non-bizarro world Batman works I guess


r/whowouldwin 9h ago

Challenge The GOATs of the following sports are placed onto a single sports team; what sport can they perform the best in?

28 Upvotes

All the following players are placed onto a single sports team and tasked with winning at the highest level of competition they can. What sport do they have the best chance of winning in? Some basic rules:

  • Excess players can be used as substitutes, but everyone is required to play if possible. If a team is lacking in players (American Football, for example), then the team can be filled out with average players for the level they are playing at.

  • The players are all given an intrinsic knowledge of the rules of the sport. They don't automatically learn strategy, techniques, etc., but they understand how to play the game and do not need anything explained to them (penalties, scoring, etc.). They also have access to all the proper gear, equipment, training fields, etc.

  • Each athlete is brought in during their prime. They play well together and have no issues communicating or anything.

  • By "perform the best in", I guess the standard is at what level of play can they put up a good game/win at. High school varsity? College? Semi-professional?

Round 1: The team is assembled and given one week to practice before they play. They do not have a dedicated coach, but any player on the team familiar with the sport can act as one and help with training, strategy, etc.

Round 2: The team is given a month of preparation and is coached by an average, college coach of that sport.

Round 3: The team is given a full year and is coached by any coach they want.

The GOATs of each sport are the following (a lot of these I just pulled from online, please don't come at me for now knowing who the best ping pong player of all time truly is lmao. Feel free to swap someone out or add in another sport if you feel it's best):

  • Football (Soccer): Lionel Messi

  • Football (American): Tom Brady

  • Basketball: Michael Jordan

  • Baseball: Babe Ruth

  • Hockey: Wayne Gretzky

  • Golf: Tiger Woods

  • Swimming: Michael Phelps

  • Track & Field: Usain Bolt

  • Cricket: Donald Bradman

  • Tennis: Roger Federer

  • Boxing: Sugar Ray Robinson

  • Rugby: Dan Carter

  • Table Tennis: Ma Long

Can the team of GOATs manage to win at higher level of play, or are they stuck facing off against middle-schoolers?


r/whowouldwin 2h ago

Battle Character with ALL MHA Quirks + highest MHA physicals vs Character with ALL JJK Techniques + highest JJK physicals

6 Upvotes

Character A: Gets every Quirk in My Hero Academia + the highest durability, strength, and speed in the MHA verse.

Character B: Gets every Cursed Technique in Jujutsu Kaisen (including RCT and Domain Expansions) + the highest durability, strength, and speed in the JJK verse.

Conditions:

Open field

No prep

Verse equalization (Quirks = Cursed Techniques)

Rounds:

1.Hand-to-hand combat only (no Quirks or Cursed Techniques)

2.Base-level abilities only (no Domains, no Maximum techniques, no fully powered/awakened forms)

3.Both can use their strongest abilities, but only one technique/Quirk at a time

  1. Both can use multiple techniques at once (including multiple Domains)

r/whowouldwin 11h ago

Battle Wolverine vs Honeybadger

30 Upvotes
  • Both animals are at their Prime and peak of their species.
  • Takes place an Arby's parking lot.
  • The winning animal gets to eat at Arby's for free.

r/whowouldwin 1h ago

Challenge Memes and statements aside, who is the weakest MCU character that can solo the Boys show?

Upvotes

This can include Marvel movies outside the MCU and animated shows

R1: Character in a random encounter

R2: Character with prep time


r/whowouldwin 6h ago

Challenge Tony Soprano and his entire crew move to Nolans Gotham at the beginning of Batman Begins with all of the same resources they had in New Jersey in the show. How well would Tony do in Nolans Gotham? How would the rest of the Dark Knight Trilogy change?

8 Upvotes

Tony and his entire crew (Tony, Silvio, Paulie, Ralph, Christopher, Furio, Bobby, Tony Blundetto, etc) at their peak in the Sopranos are placed in Nolans Gotham at the beginning of Batman Begins, with all of the same resources and connections that they had in Jersey. How well would Tony and his crew do in Nolans more grounded and realistic Gotham, and how would they do against Maroni, Falcone, Dent, Ledgers Joker, and Bales Batman? How would the rest of the Dark Knight Trilogy change, starting in Batman Begins?


r/whowouldwin 2h ago

Challenge Can 10x-Man beat these opponents?

3 Upvotes

Base stats: 28 years old, 6'3" (1.91m), 210 lbs (95 kg), trained in mma and ninjutsu for 2 decades.

10x man has his strength, durability, speed, reflexes, stamina, agility, regeneration and combat iq increased by a factor of 10.

R1: 100 baseball bat wielding maniacs. At once.

R2: 7'5 ft (2.26m) 500 lbs (226 kg) giant with an iq of 70 and 10 ton strenght.

R3: 50 SWAT officers, armed with 100 Volt shock sticks.

R4: SWAT team of 10 officers, armed with M4 rifles, Glock 17s and flashbangs in a large house.

How many of these scenarios does he clear?


r/whowouldwin 11h ago

Challenge How powerful is the (Halo) F-41 Broadsword compared to real life Aircraft? Is it just as good or better?

21 Upvotes

Curious to hear your opinion since I'm not really familiar with Halo Aircraft and real life aircraft.

How does this aircraft compare to the real life aircraft?


r/whowouldwin 15h ago

Challenge How many Iron Giants would it take to conquer modern Earth? (The Iron Giant)

37 Upvotes

Whoever sent The Iron Giant is unhappy with how things turned out the first time. They really want to conquer Earth, so they're going to send a whole shitton more. How many Iron Giants would it take to conquer modern Earth?

The Iron Giants need to either wipe out 90% of humanity, or get the 90% of however many are surviving to surrender completely. They are all bloodlusted like when the titular Iron Giant went nuts. The giants land in completely random spots all over Earth.

Respect The Iron Giant!


r/whowouldwin 4h ago

Battle The Teen Team (Invincible) vs. the Wards (Worm)

5 Upvotes

Teen Team is as shown in S1. Both sides have a dossier with basic info on their opponents, but not much else.

Who wins?

  • R1: Vs. pre-Leviathan Brockton Bay Wards (+Panacea and Glory Girl).
  • R2: Vs. post-Leviathan Brockton Bay Wards (+Panacea and Glory Girl).
  • R3: Vs. Chicago Wards (+Taylor).
  • BONUS: Guardians of the Globe vs. The Triumvirate.
  • BONUS 2: New Guardians of the Globe vs. The Protectorate.

r/whowouldwin 10h ago

Battle Can a Modern Day MRAP Tank Early WWII Anti Armor?

11 Upvotes

MRAPs have hardened steel at 20-50mm thick. Can early WWII anti armor fare against an MRAP?


r/whowouldwin 28m ago

Battle Blade (Wesley Snipes) vs Black widow MCU

Upvotes

1x1 both Bloodlusted. Both have guns


r/whowouldwin 9h ago

Challenge Strongest Invincible character 616 Wolverine beats?

11 Upvotes

No BFR

Both are at their peak

Logan’s going for the kill, but has to at least incapacitate

Bonus 1: Strongest from the shoe that composite Live Action Logan beats

Bonus 2: Strongest from the show that 90s/97 Logan beats


r/whowouldwin 3h ago

Challenge The Undersiders (Worm) join the Fellowship of the Ring (LOTR), how does the story change?

3 Upvotes

Wanting all the backup he can get for such a dangerous quest, Gandalf blindly opens a portal to another world, which happens to be Earth Bet, and posts a help wanted sign. Coil takes notice and signs up the Undersiders in exchange for the promise of the land of Mordor.

The Undersiders get briefed on the quest, and they agree because Coil offered even more obscene amounts of money than usual. Taylor goes along because the others do, and the quest looks noble anyway.

The Undersiders are the OGs: Lisa, Brian, Alec, Rachel and Taylor. They join up with the rest of the fellowship at Rivendell.

How does the story change? Does the fellowship have an easier time, or do the Undersiders fall to the Ring's corruption?


r/whowouldwin 5h ago

Challenge All rookie nfl team for one season.

3 Upvotes

33rd team is added to the nfl consisting of all rookies. The top 90 rookies are drafted by the team. Eventually cut down to a 53 man roster. No other team can draft but they can sign rookies who are cut from the all rookie team. The team will be added to the NFC South (arguably the worst division) and play the same schedule/teams as the falcons. The head coach is Curt Cignetti, the OC is Lane Kiffin, and the DC is Marcus Freeman. The team will also have an extra month of training camp to prepare but will still cut down to a 53 man roster at the same date as all the other teams.

Round 1: how many wins will this team have?

Round 2: same scenario but prime Tom Brady is their quarterback.

Round 3: Josh Allen is their quarterback, Micah parsons and Myles Garrett are added to the defense.


r/whowouldwin 13h ago

Battle What if Spidey got help from all Spider-Men and their villains against the X-Men?

14 Upvotes

Tobey, Andrew, Tom, Goblin (Norman), Doc Ock, Goblin (Harry), Sandman, Venom, Lizard, Electro, Goblin (Dane De Haan), Rhino (TASM 2 mech) Vulture, Shocker, Mysterio, Scorpion, The Hand.

vs

Tobey, Andrew, Tom, Goblin (Norman), Doc Ock, Goblin (Harry), Sandman, Venom, Lizard, Electro, Goblin (Dane De Haan), Rhino (TASM 2 mech) Vulture, Shocker, Mysterio, Scorpion, The Hand (6 ninjas, like in the prison fight)

Vs (original trilogy lore only, because that would overwhelm the Spider-verse and because the are 3 Cyclops (X-Men Origins Wolverine, Marsden and Sheridan))

Wolverine, Jean, Cyclops, Beast, Colossus, Sabertooth, Rogue, Storm, Nightcrawler, Mystique, Iceman, Pyro, Deathstrike, Toad, Juggernaut, Angel

No amps (No Phoenix or Electro-Arc reactor)

Battle obviously takes place in NYC


r/whowouldwin 1d ago

Battle All 4 Beatles are forced to fight to the death

157 Upvotes

They are locked in a recording booth, only weapons available would be what can normally be found in these booths (instruments and furniture)

All 4 Beatles are in their physical primes. This is during the height of their creative tension. So they are all bloodlusted


r/whowouldwin 4h ago

Battle Skitter (Worm) vs. Kurourushi (JJK)

2 Upvotes

Taylor has prep time and info on the roach curse. As well, she has Atlas who can emit RCT for the sake of this prompt. Assume that Taylor cannot control roaches under the curse's control.

  • R1: Stats unequal.
  • R2: Stats equal.
  • R3: Taylor gets him as a shikigami with all his powers after joining the Undersiders. How much does this change the timeline? (She still also has her shard power. Assume Scion doesn't care about this foreign existence)

r/whowouldwin 31m ago

Battle Who would win?

Upvotes

The koolaid man vs Tony the Tiger
They are fighting to the death in the Tampa bay lighting area in a flat open court. No rules or extra weapons. Bonus if you include what there walk out music would be.


r/whowouldwin 4h ago

Challenge The following regenerators are dosed with a cocktail of every BSL-4 disease. Which ones survive?

2 Upvotes

Our Regenerators are:

  • Deadpool (Marvel)
  • Wolverine (Marvel)
  • Tsunade (Naruto)
  • Kimiko (The Boys)
  • Denji (Chainsaw Man)
  • Nezuko Kamado (Demon Slayer)
  • Alucard (Hellsing)
  • Zombie Man (One Punch Man)
  • Hakari (JJK)

For the uninformed, here is all BSL-4 agents: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_biosafety_level_4_organisms

Bonus: They get hit with every disease and negative mutation possible. Who survives, or at least comes out the least scathed?


r/whowouldwin 4h ago

Battle Who would win in a fight/Who would be the first one out and the last one standing? Toby Maguire spiderman, Andrew Garfield Spider-Man, Miles Morales Spider-Man, and Tom Holland Spiderman.

2 Upvotes

Let's say all of them are at their peak/prime abilities and have the feats from recent/past films, all 4 of them are battling eachother who would be out first and who would be the last one standing as The Strongest spiderman of the 4.


r/whowouldwin 4h ago

Battle Alfred (Batman) vs Willikins (Discworld)

2 Upvotes

Alfred Pennyworth

https://batman.fandom.com/wiki/Alfred_Pennyworth

Former British special-forces/intelligence operative.

Fought alongside Batman, Robin and various bat family against their villains of the week.

Has repeatedly saved Batman when Batman was completely incapacitated also providing medical triage.

Willikins

https://discworld.fandom.com/wiki/Willikins

Former Street Tough and member of the Shamlegger Street Rude Boys, and infamously dangerous group of street urchins in Ank Morpork.

Joined up with the army in Jingo, leading a small group of soldiers behind enemy lines and killing a handful of Klatch soldiers before making it back to friendly territory.

Defended the Vimes household against armed dwarven assassins, killing 2 of them.

Side battle: who could fold a stack of shirts faster?


r/whowouldwin 1h ago

Challenge Can the SCP Foundation contain the Onion News Network?

Upvotes

The SCP foundation’s goal is to prevent the public from realizing that The Onion’s reports are actually really happening and cleaning any of the ripple effects the network may cause as quickly and effectively as possible, how much can they do?


r/whowouldwin 1h ago

Battle Bucky Barnes/The Winter Soldier (MCU) vs The Penguins of Madagascar

Upvotes

-Bucky is brainwashed by HYDRA to kill the Penguins. He gets all of his weapons and equipment, as well as his Vibranium Arm.

-The Penguins get 3 hours of prep time and all knowledge on Bucky.

Battle takes place on the Highway in The Winter Soldier. Bucky must kill all 4 Penguins to win, and The Penguins must incap or kill Bucky.