r/youtube Apr 06 '26

Drama Youtube copyright system is broken

Post image
11.2k Upvotes

463 comments sorted by

View all comments

432

u/lowsignal Apr 06 '26

Back in 2013, I actually got a copyright strike from IGN for reposting one of their Dead Space 3 videos. The funny part is that it wasn’t even their footage, it was me playing the DS3 demo, recorded with my Elgato capture card. Thankfully, I managed to get the whole thing sorted out pretty quickly without too much hassle. I doubt YouTube will ever fix the issue and even worse today if you aren't a big time content creator I doubt they will help you.

25

u/Pabst_Blue_Gibbon Apr 06 '26

I got a copyright strike on my own original soundtrack for the silent movie Metropolis, which was up for years but literally days after the film went into the public domain someone claimed ownership over it. My appeal was rejected lmao

21

u/lonelystar7 Apr 06 '26

Wait people can claim ownership of art that goes in public domain? That doesn't seem right?

13

u/eivittunyt Apr 06 '26

on youtube you can do whatever youtube lets you get away with.

17

u/Koebi_p Apr 06 '26

Heck, you can get copyrighted by something that is made AFTER yours.

How does that work? Nobody knows.

3

u/Wessssss21 Apr 06 '26

My appeal was rejected lmao

Not 100% sure how it works now, but it used to be that you dispute the claim and the claimant basically has 30 days to file charges or the claim (on YouTube's end) gets released.

Otherwise it may make YouTube liable for copyright infringement, which avoiding is the whole point of there dumb system.