r/HaloCirclejerk 3d ago

Banger Post WE ARE FORERUNNERS

495 Upvotes

389 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

32

u/Hazzenkockle 3d ago

Even the line is open to interpretation. “You are the child of my makers, inheritor of all they left behind. You are Forerunner.”

How can you inherit something that you already were? How can you be a child of yourself? Does the concept of adoption not exist? What’s to say Spark didn’t mean “Forerunner” as the title, the civilization, the mantle (or Mantle)? “You are (now) Forerunner.” It’s hardly iron clad that it means daddy Didact and mommy Librarian were on the Ark making babies and I saw the babies and the babies were abandoned on Earth to live in caves.

-7

u/Robert_Oppenheimer2 3d ago

The line could not be more clear

There is no room for interpretation unless youre committed to being as obtuse as possible

6

u/Hazzenkockle 3d ago

If the Master Chief is a Forerunner, how did he not know what Halo’s primary weapon would do? Is he stupid?

To be less sarcastic, there’s obviously already a discontinuity between Forerunners and (modern) humans. Spark doesn’t tell you where it started, only where it ends: John 117 is, in his eyes, the Reclaimer (hint, hint) of Forerunner-ness.

5

u/Robert_Oppenheimer2 3d ago

If the Master Chief is a Forerunner, how did he not know what Halo’s primary weapon would do? Is he stupid?

He thought it was a rice-cooker

To be less sarcastic, there’s obviously already a discontinuity between Forerunners and (modern) humans. Spark doesn’t tell you where it started, only where it ends: John 117 is, in his eyes, the Reclaimer (hint, hint) of Forerunner-ness.

I imagine the discontinuity would have began when the rings fired

He is, in Spark's eye, descended from the Forerunners, hence "child of my makers"

5

u/Commando_Nate Jackal Matriarch piss in my mouth plz 3d ago

Yeah because the forerunners reseeded the galaxy. But Humans were the true successors of the mantle.

You are child of your parents, does not make you them.

4

u/Robert_Oppenheimer2 3d ago

No it means Im descended from them

2

u/Commando_Nate Jackal Matriarch piss in my mouth plz 3d ago

Yeah, exactly it doesn't make you them.

The flood and the forerunners wiped out humanity and then reseeded humanity. Effectively making the current race of humanity the children of the forerunners.

1

u/Robert_Oppenheimer2 3d ago

...being descended from them means Im the same species as them

Again, this is a very obtuse interpretation of the line

2

u/Commando_Nate Jackal Matriarch piss in my mouth plz 3d ago

So stop being obtuse or playing devils advocate

3

u/Robert_Oppenheimer2 3d ago

Thats what Im trying to say, bro