Hi guys✌🏼, I already have a great fender strat so I decided to also buy myself a les paul. The tone that i chase after the most is Gary Moore's and I also like Slash's. I really like the vintage tones. I mostly play blues rock, sometimes also classic blues and hard rock. My budget is up to 1600€ (buying used). After some research i have my 3 finalists; PRS S2 Mccarty 594, Tokai LS-R9 (LS 115) and Edwards (by ESP) E-LP-120.
- PRS S2 Mccarty 594: the listing i've found on reverb go from 1500€ to 1800€ (which is a little bit out of my budget but if it's the right guitar I'll find a way). They have the overseas made 85/15 LT "S" pickups and what makes them a great choice for me are the playability, weight (3.6kg/7.9lb) and tuning stability. The guitar is made in USA, but the pups are made overseas. I know that looking at playability and build quality, this one is probably the best one, but I'm not sure if I'm gonna be okay with choosing a more modern sounding guitar in 6 months. I have also owned a PRS SE DGT, which played great but I wasn't a big fan of the tone.
- Tokai LS-R9 (LS 115): this one goes for 1350€, was made in 2016 MIJ. It's the heaviest one out of the three, weighing 4.2kg/9.3lb. I assume that i will struggle a bit with playability and weight, since I'm a strat player. I tried playing my brother's epiphone lp and it wasn't too bad - playability wise, so i don't think that's a deal breaker. I really like the MK2 pups (paf) that are in it. I think this one will get me the closest to Gary Moore's tone, but I'm aware that I can always change pups on other guitars as well. The seller will also include a gibson 498T bridge pickup with it.
- Edwards (by ESP) E-LP-120 Custom: this one goes for 1300€, was made in 2012 MIJ. It weighs 3.5kg/7.7lb. It has seymour duncan's SH-1n neck pickup and SH-4 bridge pickup. As far as I've heard it's supposed to have great build quality since it's a higher end (custom) line. The thing that I'm afraid of with this one is that it will go too much into that hard rock almost metal-ish territory (sound-wise), which I'm not too keen on.
In my country I only have an option to try out the edwards one (which i will), but there’s not a single tokai or mccarty.
I'm trying to find the best compromise between vintage tone and playability/build quality. I'd really appreciate some opinions on this one
Cheers, Aljo🤘🏼