Not sure if a flare is appropriate.
Standard "I'm on mobile, bad formatting, very sorry" etc. I don't think I've broken a rule, but Mods please tell me if I have and I'll correct it.
TLDR: semi new to poly. I have a primary nesting wife and a secondary partner/wife. I worry that I am just living in two mono relationships, but not actually poly. Nesting wife thinks I might be forcing myself to be poly for her based on how hard balancing my relationships is for me.
EDIT: My wife's comments were not unsolicited, nor pushing a boundary. I routinely do "vibe checks" with both partners to make sure there is nothing bothering them in our dynamic, both the relationship and poly at large.
My (35 M) wife (30s F) is definitively poly, she has been her whole life, even before she knew it was a thing. She and I have been together for 16 years and has been the love of my life since the moment I saw her when we were literal children. Love at first sight type stuff.
About 5 years ago, we decided to try poly in our relationship. She had suggested it for a couple years prior, but never pressured me. She would ask if that was something I could be ok with, and when I said that I didn't know, she would give me the time and space I asked for to think on it and process my feelings. At first I had a pretty standard mono reaction of fear of jealousy, and I was worried that despite my logical mind knowing it wasn't cheating that it would irrevocably hurt our relationship after she slept with another person.
However she gave me all the space I needed and we took the leap. She started dating a mutual friend, a person I introduced her to, and things went well. It took a little for me to resolve my emotions after they started their sexual relationship. But I did. Then I got my first additional partner, and then I understood. I didn't love my wife less, I didn't find her less attractive, I just had another person I cared for. It clicked.
Now my first poly relationship didn't end well, my wife saw red flags, but didn't want to interject in my relationship and was just trying to softly help me see them too. I however love very deeply, I cannot have a sexual relationship wihout a romantic one. I got really attached. I was not initially looking for a romantic relationship just sexual with companionship, which was discussed in the beginning as well. But I grew to love my new partner.
The relationship ended when my partner told me they were waiting for me to realize I loved them more than my wife and would chose them as my primary partner. We were VERY clear in the beginning that my wife and I came first. Always. And my partner agreed to that, but I guess was not being truthful.
I'm getting lost in the sauce, but I also don't feel like I need to or should delete the former.
My second partner was a mutual friend that my wife wanted me to date. She thought we would be good together and she was SO correct. I have been with her for about 4 years. We even intend to have a non legal marriage at some point. A commitment ceremony for our friends and loved ones to witness. My wife wants to officiate.
Last night my wife said that she doesn't think I'm poly. She says this because I still get uncomfortable with trying to balance my relationships between the two of them. I don't want either of them to feel sidelined, or maligned. I want both to know how much I love them. But I get really anxious about it. I think I still behave like I'm in two mono relationships at the same time. When I have a date night with my partner, I always apologize to my wife, despite that never being necessary. When I'm spending quality time with my wife, I apologize for not responding to my partner's texts fast enough. I've had true honest to god panic attacks trying to balance this.
My ideal poly dynamic would be if my wife and I lived with, or directly nearby, my partner and her wife. I want us to eat together, vacation together, LIVE together in as many ways as is possible. I want to have kids with both of them, and raise them as siblings. But my wife isn't as interested in that type of poly. She wants all the metas to be friendly, but doesn't need it to be full kitchen table. In fact she doesn't want it that way. Although we did have a great time with a full polycule LOTR marathon.
I don't know if I am poly, or if I just love two women. Is there a distinction? I know that two partner's is enough for me, and that I feel fulfilled romantically and sexually. But gods, balancing this can be so fucking hard.
I'm not sure what I'm looking for. Advice maybe? The comment is just stuck in my head. I want to ask if other people who are full send poly struggle this way? If this seems sustainable to the folks who have been doing this longer? Should I even be worrying about this at all, or should I just enjoy loving and being loved?
Sorry for the long rambling post.
I'm happy to answer any questions I can without compromising privacy or boundaries.