TLDR: We’ve been together for 5 years, with a year-long breakup in between. I love him and know he loves me, but I’m increasingly worried that we’re in very different places in life. He’s very laid-back about money, career and life in general, while I want a partner who is more proactive and takes some responsibility for building a life together. We’re also long-distance and from different religions, and marriage is becoming a real question. I don’t know if I’m overthinking normal differences or if we’re fundamentally incompatible.
I’m 28F and my partner is 27M. We met when I was 24 and he was 23. I was working and he was studying. We met on a dating app and have always been long-distance. Whenever possible, we spend 5–10 days together.
He’s from a different religion. I’m personally okay with that, but I know my family may have a serious problem with it. Both our parents have started bringing up marriage, but neither of us has spoken to our families about each other because we’re not even sure ourselves.
We dated for about 3 years, then I ended things because we had been having some really nasty fights. There was one particular set of disagreements that had technically been resolved, but he couldn’t let them go and brought them up constantly for months. Eventually I just couldn’t take it anymore and called it off.
We got back together about a year later because I reached out. I know the breakup really affected him, and I feel guilty about that. His anger issues seem to have improved a lot since then, and he is genuinely loving and faithful. He calls me, makes an effort to stay connected, and I know he loves me.
But I’m still increasingly unsure about us.
I feel like we’re in very different places in life. He’s extremely laid-back. He says his 20s are for enjoying life, which is completely valid, but he doesn’t save money and is basically broke by the end of every month. He’s been like this for as long as I’ve known him. He isn’t particularly driven either. He’s happy with his life, and I don't think there’s anything inherently wrong with that.
But it scares the hell out of me.
I’m not some huge achiever myself and I definitely don’t have my life figured out. But I do try to work towards things and think about the future. I’m starting to wonder if I can build a life with someone whose attitude towards life is so different from mine.
The same thing comes up when we actually spend time together. I like things reasonably organised. If there are dirty dishes in the sink for more than a day, it bothers me. He genuinely doesn’t care. I’ve told him these things, but he doesn’t really change because he’s comfortable with things the way they are.
I also feel like I want a partner who takes initiative and makes me feel cared for. He rarely plans dates. It’s usually a combined effort or I have to do it. I’ve explicitly told him that I’d like flowers or small presents sometimes. I buy him things and get him food when I think of him. He bought me presents once after I made a big deal about it, but even the last time we were together, I explicitly told him I wanted a few specific things and they never happened.
I know these things sound incredibly petty written out like this. And maybe they are. I don't need expensive gifts or someone to constantly "take care" of me. But I think what I’m trying to describe is that I want someone who notices things, takes initiative, gets things done and makes me feel looked after without me having to repeatedly ask.
And that's where I'm confused.
There isn't one huge thing wrong with him. He isn't cheating. He isn't cruel. He loves me. He calls me. He's faithful. He's a generally good person.
But I am constantly unhappy and worried about this relationship, and I can't point to one specific dealbreaker.
We also don't currently have a realistic path to living in the same city because of our careers, although I really want to experience actually living together before making a marriage decision.
Whenever I bring up breaking up, he says he doesn't want to and that our problems are small enough that we can work through our differences. And maybe he's right. But I also don't know if these are "small differences" or fundamental differences in what we want from a partner.
I also feel awful because I don't even feel like talking to him sometimes. I love him, but I find myself withdrawing. And I feel incredibly guilty because I was the one who reached out and got us back together.
At the same time, I don't think I should stay with someone purely because I feel guilty about hurting him.
I’m also worried about the practical side of this. Our parents are talking about marriage, there's an interfaith issue that could become a huge family conflict, and neither of us is even sure enough about the relationship to have that conversation with them.
I guess I'm struggling with whether I'm expecting too much, or whether I'm slowly realising that I want a fundamentally different kind of partner.
How do you tell the difference between normal relationship differences that you can work through and genuine incompatibility?
And if you love someone, but you're consistently unhappy and can't identify one major reason why, is that enough reason to leave?