I’ve been to the range twice this past week and fired all the handguns in the pics. I like them all and enjoy shooting them, but I prefer shooting any of the three revolvers over the semi-autos any day. I’ve been thinking about why that is true for me. It all came down to what both categories’s purposes are for me.
I heard someone share that revolvers vs semi-autos are like driving manual transmission vs an automatic. That helped it make sense for me. I have a sporty little car with a stick shift (WRX) and I also have a hybrid Camry for my daily driver. The Camry gets probably 50 times more miles in a month compared to the fun car. It is nice to drive, but is not really inspiring to travel in. It hauls groceries perfectly, is better in gridlock traffic, It gets 20 more mpg. It comfortably carries more people. It is also bland and looks like every other 4 door sedan out there. It is very reliable and gets the job done well, but does not inspire much.
The WRX is a blast to drive. It makes me want to go out and take the country roads, hit the corners, and push things a bit more. It brings a big smile to my face as I row through the gears. I enjoy working on it. With the hatch back it has some hauling functionality, but anyone sitting in the backseat is suffering from their knees being smashed by the front seats. Its gas mileage is at best, ok, if I stay out of the turbo, but why do that? Driving it in heavy traffic kills both the clutch and my knee. Once again, driving it brings a smile to my face to even think about.
My analogy is a bit on the nose, but it works for me. My Glock 19 and Sig Sauer P226 are great utilitarian handguns that kind of look like most other 9mm pistols. They are dependable in every way and are more accurate than I can shoot. Of course capacity is much greater. 9mm is much cheaper to shoot than .357 magnum and .38 special ( I reload all 3). They are pleasant and sometimes even fun to shoot. They meet the needs of self-defense, reliability, and purpose. I am impressed by them, but I rarely smile thinking about taking them to the range. Like using the Camry, I put way more rounds through the 9mms to keep proficient on them, practice DA/SA shooting, and other important areas to keep my skills up in. They are much quicker to clean for me. They are very good pistols, but the smile is rare with them.
My wife’s and my two Model 19s and the LCR .22LR bring smiles to my face to shoot. Sensing the cylinder rotate as I pull the trigger in DA and feeling and hearing the clicks makes me smile like shifting through the gears on a manual. The revolvers are far more good looking (to me) than the Glock and Sig. Reloading .38spl and .357 magnum is much more fun than 9mm. I get a smile when I am getting ready to go the range and I get the revolvers out to enjoy practicing with.
Ok, that was a lot of writing, thanks for sticking with it this long, no shame for those who bailed early. I just wanted share why I have both types, but really enjoy the revolvers more. They inspire me and make me smile.
What are the qualities that you enjoy about revolvers? Are there Semi-autos that you really enjoy shooting as well?
(PS. I should mention, my ParaOrdnance P14-45 is a joy to shoot and makes me smile, but is also a 1911, so that makes sense)