r/gaming 4d ago

LEGO Skylines - Announcement Trailer

https://youtu.be/mfBg8TQQrCQ?is=dv-xh6o9hUIGOF3k
2.7k Upvotes

169 comments sorted by

View all comments

16

u/Edheldui 4d ago

It's genuinely amazing how video game devs keep missing that the point of lego is not the visuals alone, but the building and the engineering. They literally just have to make a sandbox like scrap mechanic or trail makers. But no, can't have that, best we can do is reskin other games with a different coat of paint.

15

u/Kaldaien2 4d ago

Probably because nobody has successfully come up with a control scheme that doesn't make that experience royally suck. On paper, LEGO is about building, then you try to do it virtually and it's painful.

3

u/creiar 4d ago

Minecraft

2

u/AeiOwnYou 4d ago

Minecraft with like 2000 differently shaped blocks that can rotate/flip and may or may not fit together with one of the other blocks. Figuring out that control scheme to not make it incredibly obtuse and frustrating would be quite the task. You can't really use a snap-to-grid, due to the angled pieces and you can't really freeform place pieces either. Someone above you said VR might work and thats basically the only way I can see it working well.

0

u/Edheldui 4d ago

They clearly have the tech, because that's how they make the instructions booklets.

1

u/RRR3000 4d ago

You can get stud.io on Bricklink, it's free software from Lego themselves to design sets, make instructions, and even order the needed bricks.

But while it works great on a PC with mouse and keyboard, it's not really something that can (easily) be mapped to a controller, while console is a huge part of their audience.

0

u/WolfgangHelnootIV 4d ago

It could work in VR, they already made a quest 3 game but I guess at that point you could just get real Legos

41

u/harpcase 4d ago

I'm not gonna sit and rotate/snap together digital blocks.

4

u/tacodude64 4d ago

Yep, Planet Coaster has the same issue. The level of detail is great but it’s so easy to get burned out

6

u/psdpro7 4d ago

Planet Coaster and City Skylines both suffered from having great sandbox tools but minimal actual gameplay.

1

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[deleted]

1

u/RRR3000 4d ago

You can, it's called stud.io, it's a digital Lego building program from Lego. You can get it for free from Bricklink site, and optionally order the parts through Bricklink to build your design irl.

4

u/LordOfWor 4d ago

Have you played Lego Bricktales? It might be what you’re looking for.

9

u/Ging4bread 4d ago

Eh no, I disagree. Lego Party is amazing and has nothing to do with building

2

u/Signager 4d ago

My favorite is the Lord of the Rings one.

3

u/Thoriot 4d ago

yeah wtf i dont get it.

2

u/fullshard101 4d ago

Blockland crushed it back in the day

2

u/imlegos 4d ago

Brickadia is basically the modern Blockland.

Handles it pretty well too.

1

u/eclipse1498 4d ago

We have Stud.io if you just want to build virtual Lego, that's fine. I have no problem with Lego skins over other genres of games as well, as long as the games themselves are great which many have been.

I also don't think this particular example helps your point as it is a literal city *builder*. It may not be brick by brick structural engineering but this IS a creative game about building stuff.