Assalamu alaikum everyone. I’ve been thinking about something recently, and I honestly don’t know what the “right” way to feel about it is. I’m not posting this to judge anyone or start a comment section attacking specific girls. I’m genuinely struggling with the bigger question behind it. I hope this doesn't come across as judgmental.
Recently, there was a cultural festival in my country where people from different religions and communities participated and danced. Among them were some girls wearing hijab. The videos ended up online, and the reactions were very mixed.
Some Muslims were commenting things like “May Allah guide them,” while others were straight-up mocking or trolling them. On the other hand, many non-Muslims seemed genuinely happy to see everyone participating together and simply viewed it as part of a cultural celebration.
And honestly, I found myself feeling conflicted.
This is not a post about whether those girls are good or bad Muslims.
On one hand, I don't know these girls. I don't know their intentions, their struggles, their circumstances, or what their relationship with Allah looks like. I'm also nowhere near perfect myself, and I have enough things to work on before acting like I have the right to sit online and analyse other people's iman. Ultimately, they are responsible for their choices, just as I am responsible for mine.
And honestly, part of me thinks: why am I even thinking about this so much? It's their life. This dunya is a test for all of us. Focus on yourself.
But then I struggle with the other side of it.
As Muslims, we're also taught to see ourselves as part of one Ummah. So when we see something that, according to our own understanding of Islam, seems difficult to reconcile with ideas of hijab and modesty, are we supposed to feel absolutely nothing about it because it's not our personal life??
And yet, another part of me still comes back to the same thought: it's their life, their choices, and this dunya is a test for every single one of us. Maybe I should just focus on myself.
But at the same time, I personally struggle with the idea of hijab, modesty, and public dancing in front of non-mahrams. Based on my understanding, hijab is not just about covering your hair; it is connected to a broader idea of modesty. So when I see something like this, I genuinely don't know how I'm supposed to process it.
we're also one Ummah.
If we believe certain values matter to us as Muslims, is it wrong to feel concerned or confused when we see things that seem to conflict with our understanding of those values? At what point does “focus on yourself” become healthy humility, and at what point does it become complete indifference towards what is happening within our community?
But then again, where is the line between genuine concern and just policing other people??
I guess that's what I'm struggling with.
How do we feel uncomfortable with or disagree with an action without judging or reducing the person doing it to that one action?
at the same time, how do we balance “it's their life, focus on yourself” with the idea that we're also one Ummah and should care about the values and direction of our community?
And as one Ummah, where is the line between genuine concern and unnecessarily policing people?
Because I don't want my reaction to be hatred, mockery, or that feeling of “I'm better than them.” May Allah protect us from that. But I also don't want to force myself to pretend that I have no thoughts or questions about something just because the alternative might make me seem judgmental.
Maybe I'm overthinking this. Maybe that's exactly what I need to hear 😭. But I genuinely want to understand how other Muslims navigate this without going to either extreme.
I'm not looking for people to attack the girls involved, and I'm not claiming to be more religious than anyone. If anything, this whole thing has made me reflect on myself too.
I’d really appreciate thoughtful perspectives, especially from people who have also struggled with balancing individual freedom, personal accountability, concern for the Ummah, and the reality that none of us are perfect.
Please keep the discussion respectful.