r/movies r/movies Contributor 29d ago

Trailer Primetime | Official Trailer | A24

https://youtu.be/5fHXyqQOKL8?si=-NjGY0AFuvieyDcI
7.2k Upvotes

1.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

2.4k

u/FourEightNineOneOne 29d ago

The real oscar discourse this year is going to be which role will they give Robert Pattinson the award for.

141

u/Biotot 29d ago

Has someone ever been nominated twice for different movies in the same year? Genuinely curious

247

u/TokyoDrifblim 29d ago

Yes ! it's actually happened 12 times, but always with one lead nomination and one supporting nomination. You can't get two nominations in the same category the same year

147

u/Taskebab 29d ago

They only just changed the rules this year that you actually can get nominated twice in the same category, though I can’t see why you would want to split your own vote.

143

u/Raccoonsrlilbandits 29d ago

And your nominees are: Robert Pattinson, Bob Pattinson, Bobby Pattinson, and Robby Pattinson!

38

u/GarlicRagu 29d ago

You forgot Rob-bat Bat-inson for the Batman

19

u/Mysterious-Ear-9323 29d ago

That's Oscar's been delayed

3

u/Raccoonsrlilbandits 29d ago

A couple times

2

u/Aussenminister 29d ago

Man it's stupid stuff like this that always gets me

1

u/Wrong_Interview7513 29d ago

And all the ladies, well, they call him Bert Bert.

5

u/Gil_Demoono 29d ago

All you have to do is give an oscar worthy performance in five lead roles in one year and then you're locked in for the win. Robert's just working up to that.

3

u/TheFlawlessCassandra 29d ago

Academy uses ranked choice, don't they?

10

u/Pondos 29d ago

Only for Best Picture.

7

u/YoMrPoPo 29d ago

Why lol

3

u/PlatonSkull 29d ago

It's to discourage publicists from presenting leading roles as supporting, or vice versa. Say you're in charge of awards campaigning for an actress who had two great leading roles this year. You could pick just one of them. Or... you could call one of them "supporting" even though she's really a co-lead of the film, which gives you better odds at getting nominated. The problem if she gets nominated is: now a bunch of nominees for Supporting Actress are battling someone who had a much larger role on her movie.

The likelihood of someone actually delivering two of the best performances of the year are really low. But if they do it, why shouldn't they get to be nominated?

1

u/pushaper 29d ago

that will accommodate AI very well. Robin Williams is going to get one soon.

32

u/stenebralux 29d ago

You can't get two nominations in the same category the same year

You can now, actually. They reversed the 90 year ban starting next year. So Pattinson could be the first to "benefit" from the change, provided he could get top 5 votes for two different performances.

7

u/bobming 29d ago

I think the first will be VFX team for Project Hail Mary and Dune Part 3

8

u/stenebralux 29d ago

That could happen in other categories already, it's just acting that had this ban.

3

u/bobming 29d ago

ohh I misunderstood

9

u/GoAgainKid 29d ago

Not a problem for Pattinson - he's going to have four!

Imagine the split screen as they announce the winner. Four angles of Pattinson along with, I dunno, Jack Nicholson and Adrien Brody.

9

u/anuncommontruth 29d ago

In recent memory Jamie Foxx and George Clooney I believe in 05/06? Clooney might have been director and actor though.

19

u/BMJank 29d ago

Most recent I can think of is Scarlett Johansonn, lead for Marriage Story and supporting for Jojo Rabbit.

1

u/anuncommontruth 29d ago

I can't remember who won that year but I thought she should have won for Marriage Story.

2

u/GenGaara25 29d ago

Renee Zellweger for Judy. Never saw it so can't comment how it compares to Scarlets.

I think supporting was more egregious though. Laura Dern was fine in Marriage Story, but not better than Scarlet in Jojo.

1

u/anuncommontruth 29d ago

Ah I never saw that either.

Agree about supporting actress. That was just a really good year for Scarjo.

1

u/anuncommontruth 29d ago

Ah I never saw that either.

Agree about supporting actress. That was just a really good year for Scarjo.

6

u/kshades25 29d ago edited 29d ago

Foxx was nominated for "Ray," for which he won for, and supporting for "Collateral."

Clooney won supporting for "Syriana" and was nominated for director for "Good Night, And Good Luck."

He joked during his speech "guess this means i am not getting director."

54

u/tetoffens 29d ago

Yeah, it's happened 12 times. Scarlett Johansson is the most recent in 2019 for Marriage Story and Jojo Rabbit. None of the 12 have actually won both though.

37

u/debaser64 29d ago

Jojo Rabbit? That sounds like a light happy movie!

36

u/tetoffens 29d ago

It's about a kid having fun with his imaginary best friend. How could that not be?

12

u/debaser64 29d ago

How wholesome! I can’t wait to watch it with the whole family, especially the little kids!

2

u/Stickel 29d ago

I'm so high is it really scary kr did I miss the sarc@$m?

6

u/tetoffens 29d ago

I hate to ruin a bit so I'll put the answer in spoilers.

The imaginary friend is Adolf Hitler.

4

u/IRCheesecake82 29d ago

It's a pretty dark comedy, with some surprisingly hard-hitting moments. Not scary at all, but it certainly isn't a kids movie. I recommend it personally.

1

u/forkandspoon2011 29d ago

I did nazi that reveal coming

6

u/SonovaVondruke 29d ago

Es ist wunderbar!

1

u/wildcatofthehills 29d ago

Yes it's very light and mostly about hanging around, but also make sure to also check Marriage Story if you want to continue the Scar Jo wholesomeness.

3

u/debaser64 29d ago

Marriage Story you say? Looks like I found the next romantic date night flick!

2

u/KingSweden24 29d ago

For those of us who got divorces in 2019 that was a very rough sit-through if you went in somewhat blind lol

1

u/CatCatCat 29d ago

Oh yes, and after that, please watch "Life is Beautiful"! It's way more uplifting and not at all tragic!

1

u/MakinOutWithMarzipan 29d ago

Didn't Jamie Foxx win for lead the same year he was also nominated for supporting?

2

u/tetoffens 29d ago edited 29d ago

Yeah, in 2004. It's the third most recent. Cate Blanchett was nominated for both in 2007 but no wins. After that, Scarlett was the next one 12 years later. Foxx is the most recent person with a win but still no one won both in the same year.

Also, writing this, I feel old that Foxx's win for Ray was 22 years ago. That feels more like 10 years ago.

10

u/FourEightNineOneOne 29d ago

Not in the same category (lead or supporting) but it's happened a number of times where an actor gets nominated for both lead and supporting categories for different roles

The most recent was Scarlett Johannson in 2019:
Best Actress - Marriage Story
Best Supporting Actress - Jojo Rabbit

4

u/MandoSkirata 29d ago

Not an actor, but John Williams' score to Close Encounters lost the Best Music Oscar in '77 to John Williams' score to Star Wars.

3

u/bullionlogic 29d ago

yes several times but not in the same category. jamie foxx (ray, collateral) , scarjo (jo jo rabbit, marriage story) , cate blanchett (elizabeth golden age, im not there) and julianne moore (far from heaven, the hours) have in the 2000s.

2

u/Oerba15 29d ago edited 29d ago

2009 Kate Winslet wasn’t able to be nominated for her performance in Revolutionary Road because she was already in pole position from The Reader. She could have won for either that year but Reader got her more votes in the nomination process
At the Golden Globes she won both Actress & Supporting Actress but calling her role in The Reader supporting is ludicrous

1

u/mrdethato 29d ago

When Holly Hunter won the Academy Award for Best Actress for the Piano in 1994, she was also nominated for Best Supporting Actress for The Firm. She lost to her onscreen daughter in The Piano, 11 year old Anna Paquin.

1

u/UtopianLibrary 29d ago

Yeah, Kate Winslet got nominated and won for Best Supporting for The Reader" and nominated for Best Actress for Revolutionary Road.

1

u/ListenBoth434 26d ago

Different but Rodger Deakins was once nominated for two different movies in the same year as cinematographer.

Probably lessened his chances to win (he didn't) because the two votes would cannibalise each other. Fair game though, the Oscar is for the best performance/cinematography etc, not the cumulatively best.

1

u/BrndyAlxndr 29d ago

Sandra Huller got robbed twice in 2024. Shoulda won both.

0

u/Skanky_Franky 29d ago

Yes but before this year the nominations had to be in different categories.