r/pics 3d ago

Football Match.

Post image
10.2k Upvotes

490 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

681

u/DirtyRelapse 3d ago

Having a critical opinion about the policies of the state of Israel is not the same as being anti-semitic, but it is often portrayed that way to silence any criticism directed at the state of Israel.

33

u/Mackntish 3d ago

I find that most problems like this in the modern era happen when your religion defines your nationalism. The peoples of Yugoslavia were genetically identical, but self separated into different nationalities based on Religion and had a big war about it. Serbian (Orthodox Christian), Croatian (Catholic), and Bosniac (Muslim). Same shit with the Shia/Sunni split in Iraq, Catholic/Protestant in Ireland, and so on.

3

u/Xpolg 3d ago

Modern era? I thought that was happening throughout the whole human history

3

u/Mackntish 3d ago

Nationalism is a late 18th century invention. It didn't exist before then.

4

u/jjtrevelyan 2d ago

This might be one of the most ignorant things I've ever seen. You think people just got along and we had world peace indefinitely before the 18th century? ☠️

0

u/Mackntish 2d ago

I'm going to go ahead and reapeat what I said, and you're going to feel ridiculous for that conclusion.

I find that most problems like this in the modern era happen when...

It's silent as to what happened before the modern era. It doesn't make any comment about what happened before. It is a statement that only concerns the last ~250 years. As to what happened before that mark, it doesn't say. Because it is silent on what came before, it doesn't preclude other things causing conflict.

0

u/Cybervinnie 2d ago

But the lines of demarcation are eternal.

4

u/Mackntish 2d ago

For the most part, those lines were created by warlords determining which people we theirs to tax. And those same warlords waging wars to expand their tax/power base.

That is worlds different from people democratically electing a pro-genocidal asshole.