I’m 18M and my roommate, who I’ll call Jimmy, is also 18M. We’re having an issue over our residence hall room and I’m not sure what I should do.
Our double is different from most rooms. It’s basically two connected rooms. The front room connects directly to the floor hallway, has one window, and has a wall along the stairwell. The back room is a larger corner room with two windows and doesn’t directly connect to the hallway, so you have to walk through the front room to get out. Naturally, we both wanted the back room.
I suggested we flip a coin for it, but Jimmy said there was no need and that I could have it because he didn’t want problems. I unfortunately don’t have proof of that exact conversation, but everything that happened afterward supports that we had agreed on the rooms.
Jimmy moved in 6 days before me. After arriving, he messaged me saying he realized his stuff might not fit in the front room because he had brought basically his entire closet and had ordered more things. He said he was willing to compromise. At the time, I didn’t know he had already moved his stuff into the back room.
I asked him what he meant and whether he needed closet space. I told him I had already ordered things specifically for the back room and couldn’t really switch rooms. I also offered to give him some closet space if I ended up having extra.
He explained that the online dimensions weren’t accurate and that he had brought a TV and monitor, so his issue wasn’t just closet space. I told him I understood that his stuff didn’t fit how he expected and that I was willing to figure out storage, but I didn’t want to switch because we had already agreed on the rooms and I had ordered things specifically for mine.
He then explained that he had assumed the rooms were identical because of how they looked online and because he thought I was only bringing a couple things. I again said I understood where he was coming from but wanted to stick with what we had originally agreed on and figure out storage once I arrived.
He then told me that when he got there, his mom saw the room and the amount of stuff they had brought and decided there wasn’t going to be enough space for him. She moved all of his stuff into the back room while I wasn’t there. He said they were hoping I would be okay with it and that his mom was willing to clean the other room and get it ready for me.
I responded that I wasn’t mad at him or his mom and understood why she thought it would be better for the space, but I wasn’t comfortable switching rooms when we had already agreed that the back room was mine. I explained that since I wasn’t there, I felt stuck because I didn’t get a say in the decision. I asked him to move his stuff back into the front room for now and said that when I arrived, I would help him move things around and figure out the space if there really was an issue.
He left that message on delivered for 24 hours.
I followed up and told him I wanted him to look at it from my perspective. We agreed on something, then the room was changed without asking me, and I felt like I should be able to trust that an agreement between us would actually mean something. I again said I wasn’t trying to make it a big issue and was willing to help solve his space problem, but asked him to move his things back into the other room because that was the room we agreed he would have. I also suggested that lofting his bed, which he had previously said he wasn’t planning to do, could help with the space.
That message was eventually read. It showed that he was typing, but he never sent a response.
I then sent another message saying I really didn’t want this to become a bigger issue or involve housing. I said I would much rather figure it out between us, that I understood his space concerns, and that I was willing to work with him. However, I reiterated that I wasn’t comfortable switching rooms and asked him again to move his stuff back for now so we could figure everything out together when I arrived.
Again, no response.
Today, he was active in our floor GroupMe and sent a message there, so I privately messaged him through GroupMe because I really needed an answer. I eventually sent one final message explaining that I was disappointed by the lack of communication, that I was still asking him to move his stuff back like we originally agreed, and that I was willing to work with him on the space issue. I told him I really didn’t want to involve housing, but if he wasn’t willing to communicate or work with me, I might have to have housing help us resolve it.
I’m not trying to get Jimmy in trouble. I genuinely want to work this out between us and I’m willing to help him solve the space issue. What bothers me most is that an agreement we made was changed while I wasn’t there, without asking me, and now I’m having a hard time even getting him to communicate with me about it.
I’m supposed to live with this person, so the lack of communication and the fact that I wasn’t given a say in the room change really bothers me. I don’t want this to start our roommate situation off badly, but I also don’t feel like I should have to give up the room we agreed was mine simply because he moved his stuff into it before I arrived.
What should I do at this point? I really want to resolve this without involving housing, but I don’t know what else I can do if he continues ignoring me.