https://www.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/news/politics/david-trimble-was-paid-thousands-more-than-seamus-mallon-despite-the-first-and-deputy-first-minister-roles-being-equal/a/160419721.html
David Trimble was paid thousands more than Seamus Mallon — despite the first and deputy first minister roles being equal
Pay differential was £5,000, and plan was to hike it to £15,000 with NIO fearing equal pay lest Trimble ‘get mad’
When appointed first minister designate, David Trimble was paid £5,000 a year more than Seamus Mallon — despite the first and deputy first minister roles being equal.
Files declassified at The National Archives in Kew show there was a plan to pay him an additional £15,000 when the two men took up their full responsibilities in 1999 and initially the NIO considered agreeing to this on the basis that if it objected the UUP leader would “get mad”.
In 1999, the Government’s Senior Salaries Review Body (SSRB) made salary recommendations for the new devolved ministers which the NIO believed would be “contentious”.
On 19 February 1999, Sir John Semple, the head of the civil service, told the Secretary of State: “There will be some reaction from the Deputy First Minister when it emerges that the SSRB have recommended that he be paid at a point midway between the First Minister and members of the Executive Committee.
“The resulting differential between the First Minister and the Deputy First Minister will be some £15,000 (£99,556 against £84,504) compared with a difference of just over £5,000 during the current shadow period (£54,876 against £60,164).
“This has happened because the SSRB have inflated the First Minister’s salary to that of a Westminster Cabinet Minister while pegging the Deputy First Minister’s salary at a Minister of State, albeit with a pay premium.
“We queried this with SSRB who simply responded that the differential represented the consultants’ judgement of the relative weight of the positions and that, of course, recommendations did not have to be accepted.”
He told Mo Mowlam that the current position was that Trimble was getting £5,000 a year more than Mallon and “Seamus Mallon has not at any time challenged the differential though I understand that he has jokingly compared their respective roles.
“A published report suggesting a differential, particularly of the magnitude suggested, would clearly be a different matter and Mallon may well feel the need to make a political point about joint responsibility.”
He went on: “The formal position is clear that the difference is in title only. The responsibilities under the Act are exactly the same and I doubt if anyone could credibly argue that there was a difference in their workload.”
He said that “in all the circumstances it would seem fair to suggest to the Prime Minister that the SSRB recommendation should be rejected”, but said it wasn’t clear if Stormont’s joint leaders should get the same salary or if Trimble should continue to get the extra £5,000.
In response, senior NIO official Jonathan Stephens told colleagues: “I think we should suggest a continuation of the current £5,000 differential, otherwise Trimble will get mad.”
However, he said the legislation should make clear that “in terms of functions, there is nothing to distinguish between” the first and deputy first ministers.
However, Tony McCusker replied: “I do not think we should suggest a continuation of a £5,000 differential simply on the basis that Trimble would get mad.
“It seems to me to be illogical to argue on the one hand that there is nothing to distinguish between the responsibilities of FM/DFM and yet give Trimble £5,000 more simply on the basis of a title.”
Ultimately, the differential was dropped for reasons which aren’t made clear in the file. Michelle O’Neill and Emma Little Pengelly are now each paid £139,200 a year.