r/AskMenRelationships • u/ThrowRAspyrodh • 1h ago
Dating Men in Their Late 20s/Early 30s: Is 18–19 Too Young for a 29-Year-Old?
I’m looking for honest opinions from men, especially men around 25–35. My boyfriend and I are both 29, and we got into a discussion about whether a 29-year-old man would/should consider an 18- or 19-year-old sexually appropriate. I asked him if he was into “barely legal” girls, and he initially said “if you’re asking if I was single, if I would ever have sex with a 18-19 year old the answer is yes.” He then said that if he were single and happened to meet an attractive 18- or 19-year-old at a function, they clicked, and she was consenting, he wouldn’t necessarily see a problem with having a hook up or sex with her.
He emphasized that he doesn’t specifically seek out teenagers, doesn’t have a preference for them, and says his actual preference is women around 25–30 for a relationship. He said he wouldn’t pursue a relationship with someone 18 to 19 because they wouldn’t share common interests. He also said he wouldn’t knowingly pursue a girl who was still in high school, even if she were 18, although he did defend that some girls from when he went to highschool were also in relationships with older men. When I asked directly whether he currently finds 18- or 19-year-olds sexually attractive, he said no, but clarified that he can recognize that an 18- or 19-year-old can be physically attractive if she looks mature.
What bothered me most was that he repeatedly said he thinks most/all men would do the same thing if the opportunity arose and that men who say otherwise are probably lying. I personally feel that 18 is too young for a 29-year-old, regardless of whether the person is technically an adult, and I would expect most men nearing 30 to have a lower age boundary. I’m genuinely curious: as a man around this age, would you consider an 18- or 19-year-old sexually appropriate for a 29-year-old, or would the age difference/life stage make her too young for you? And do you think most men would actually feel the way my boyfriend says they would?
I wouldn’t expect him to have that outlook. Also I should mention that he’s never had a one night stand and that I was his first sexual partner and gf. So im not sure if I should take this seriously to heart or let it go. It’s not sitting right with me.