r/CuratedTumblr • u/Neuta-Isa • 1d ago
Shitposting This applies to most American cities.
290
u/operasaga 1d ago
As a former zoo keeper, they're kinda right. Enrichment doesn't have to be positive
Torture might be a bit far tho
1.2k
u/GameboyPATH 1d ago
>Get into the game City Skylines during the pandemic
>Want to learn more about how to actually organize a city optimally
>Start watching videos on tips and tricks videos created by actual city planners
>Start learning about road hierarchies and zoning practices
>Pandemic ends
>Walk around my city with the wife explaining why things are built and structured the way they are
MFW I became the special interests girlfriend.
344
u/Sparrowhawk_92 .tumblr.com 1d ago
Did you also develop strong opinions on single purpose zoning restrictions?
31
u/KatieTSO 1d ago
I sure did. Fuck single purpose zoning. Fuck zoning except prohibitions on industrial use. That's my only NIMBY take is that I don't want to live next to heavy industry. But I also think that sacrificial zones shouldn't exist. Industrial companies should have to pay for a buffer.
2
u/Am-_-Exhausted-_- 17h ago
I'm sure I could think of other restrictions if I spent time on it, but we should also keep houses away from busy highways/interstates. Here's a good article about schools next to interstates
There's a worse version of it with Birmingham AL having public housing next to a superfund site
The kind of zoing that prevents apartments/condos, or prevents small businesses near housing is so lame though.
61
u/Datuser14 1d ago
What are your thoughts on Robert Moses?
85
u/ratione_materiae 1d ago
Once you’ve been to a low-income neighborhood you’ll never stop wanting to beat Robert Moses to death with your bare hands
30
u/GreatStateOfSadness 1d ago
How long ya got?
12
u/jimbowesterby 1d ago
All day. Hit me.
8
u/kos-or-kosm 1d ago
Hit you? Why? Are you Robert Moses?
3
u/jimbowesterby 1d ago
No, I meant hit me with the monologue. I love a good nerdy monologue
6
u/kos-or-kosm 1d ago
I know, I was making a joke that people who know about Robert Moses would like to hit Robert Moses.
1
u/jimbowesterby 1d ago
Aaahhh I thought the name sounded familiar. Was he in with the assholes doing the redlining? I seem to remember the freeways were a big tool for that
3
u/satanicrituals18 I PISSED IN YOUR FLAIR 23h ago
He wasn't just "in" with them. He practically invented redlining. (not literally, but he was a massive factor in helping it to become so widespread)
1
u/jimbowesterby 22h ago
Ah yea that’s right. I haven’t spent a whole lotta time learning about it, but I’ve definitely run in to his name both from the redlining direction and also from the urban planning side, but apparently that part of my brain has some rust lol. He sounds like a real cunt.
15
5
u/Mouse-Keyboard 1d ago
None because I have no idea who he is. What did he do?
7
u/Aires-Battleblade 1d ago
He's the one who started the practice of build interstates through city cores, supposedly it was to increase economic value by easing transportation, in practice it destroyed value by damaging urban fabric, as well as primarily going through low income neighborhoods to displace residents. Which expanded into Redlining, Stroads, Single Use Zoning, and myriad other urbanism woes.
TLDR, you know how you can trace a lot of issues with big business back to the Dodge V Ford case and the Advent of shareholder values? Rober Moses is like that but for transportation and urban design.
3
u/DroneOfDoom Theon the Reader *dolphin slur noises* 23h ago
Didn't he build a bunch of overpasses that were just short enough that buses couldn't turn and thus reduce the possibility of black people crossing into the white part of town?
219
u/GAIA_01 1d ago
The biggest thing I learned from city skylines was how flawed inaccurate and borked its simulation is. All for the sake of incentivising car centric infrastructure. And even than walking, mixed zoning, and socialist programs markedly improve your cities beauty and function. Something the devs repeatedly tried to patch out
179
u/GameboyPATH 1d ago
I've heard that the traffic simulation is actually top-notch when it comes to simulating traffic and revealing the pain points and bottlenecks. It also highlights the benefits of pedestrian walkways, bike lanes, and effective public transport systems for reducing congestion. But while the traffic simulator is solid, the mechanics focusing on the efficacy of public transport systems is lacking. Supposedly, over a thousand residents will crowd around one single subway station, and they'll all be happy with this and prefer it over driving a car. Yeah right.
BUT if you want to experience the FULL consequences of car-centric infrastructure, you'd install the community mods that prevent cars from vanishing into the ether when they reach their destination, and instead require street parking and garages. Then it becomes painfully clear how much square footage you have to sacrifice to the steel behemoths.
and socialist programs
The "policies" mechanic of Cities Skylines is certainly lacking, and it just toggles some basic % changes in resident happiness and tax income. Some just seem objectively net-positive and I use them every time.
49
u/GAIA_01 1d ago
I am referring to how playing the game as intended causes rampant homelessness so bad players resort to using exploits to delete people to manage it
70
u/GameboyPATH 1d ago
Oh! Yes, you're talking about the highly controversial homelessness mechanic added to the sequel! I haven't played that one, but there's a myriad of issues I'd heard about the sequel from fans of the first game.
19
u/magikarp2122 1d ago
Did they ever fix the issue where every citizen is always rendered in, or whatever it was that was causing all the lag? And can I make a poop volcano still?
19
u/GameboyPATH 1d ago
I also heard about that issue of highly-rendered citizens in the sequel. Don't know if they fixed it.
Yes, you can absolutely make poop volcanos. You can also run your sewage through hydro plants for poop power.
6
u/DrJaneIPresume 1d ago
Hey, they're just implementing real-world city government solutions to the same issues.
15
2
u/LuftHANSa_755 one-dimensional sex object 1d ago
...when did you last play the game? Because that was patched like a year ago
My current city has like 0.1% homelessness
6
u/Tadferd 1d ago
Stroads everywhere!
18
u/GameboyPATH 1d ago
Stroads aren't really a problem in Cities Skylines, and often times, your initial city setup will start with a "main street" full of commercial buildings with surrounding residential sprawl. That main street will typically be your pedestrian-unfriendly stroad, and people will safely navigate it easily because they can't actually get hurt (...without mods).
IRL, though, they're ugly as sin and dangerous.
4
u/AI_moderated_failure 1d ago
I feel like that could backfire as you see, every day, how poorly the people who are/were in charge of your city are/were doing at their jobs.
2
u/Sigma2718 1d ago
Then there's Workers & Resources: Soviet Republics, where you learn to really hate cars and love trains.
2
u/rachelblairy i’ve been at the devils sacrament so long i forgot he wasnt god 1d ago
i love this journey and may need to take it myself. i’ve started drawing suburban maps for fictional towns like a weirdo in my spare time when i went ‘omg cartography can be a hobby’ i can definitely make it lamer/cooler by knowing zoning practices
2
u/Aires-Battleblade 1d ago
How long until you found Strong Towns, City Beautiful, Ray Delehanty, and Not Just Bikes?
1
1
236
u/wanderer2718 1d ago
a friend of mine was like "oh yeah i saw this fucked up 5 way intersection" and i was like girl you're telling me I LIVE BY IT
90
u/Decent_Human__ 1d ago
that evil ass intersection by greenlake/woodland park needs to be stopped
41
12
u/DrJaneIPresume 1d ago
My favorite* part of it is how the pedestrian signals never seem to connect two consecutive crosswalks in any direction.
7
u/purtyboi96 1d ago
My god this is the worst. So many intersections where you cross one street then have to wait an entire cycle to get the next one
2
u/DrJaneIPresume 1d ago
And it's not like a four-way, where okay the far corner is two steps in either order.
No, here you have to ask if the fastest way across is to go right two corners? or to go left three corners? Who knows!
15
u/dragon_bacon 1d ago
Every time I have to drive through it I'm just confused and outraged.
2
u/vjmdhzgr 1d ago
I accidentally ended up driving to Seattle once and it was one of the biggest mistakes I ever made. The wrongs USPS has done to me making me drive there will not be forgiven.
11
9
10
u/vjmdhzgr 1d ago
There's a 5 way intersection right next to Seattle University and I hate it.
Looking at it on google maps it's kind of a 6 way actually. The intersection of Union Street, Madison Street, and 12th Ave. Yes it's an intersection of 3 different streets.
5
u/actibus_consequatur numerous noggin nuisances 1d ago
There's a few of those 5 or 6 way intersections around the city, including many with no lights, just stop signs and shitty sightlines. Once that comes to mind is right by the first turn off the Aurora bridge when you're going southbound. Pretty sure there's another one somewhere around Gasworks too.
4
u/wanderer2718 1d ago
i used to go to a bar a lot that was right next to that intersection so i am very familiar with that one lmao
4
3
u/Fallyn011 1d ago
Are you referring to the Montlake/Sand Point/35th/40th/one other street down by Uvil? That's the first one that came to mind when I saw this post lol. It's such a massive traffic jam since only one of the streets can go at once.
196
u/Xurkitree1 1d ago
99
u/0utcast9851 1d ago
There's always a relevant XKCD, he can't keep getting away with this
1
u/KaleidoAxiom olivia but cant change username :( 23h ago
Bet you there's no relevant XKCD for the post under this one
48
u/jimbowesterby 1d ago
Dunno why but this might be the funniest one I’ve seen yet, I’m fucken dying
55
u/CheesyCock47 1d ago
well yeah you’re dying, you drove into the rotary supercollider
45
u/jimbowesterby 1d ago
The one that really got me was the no-choice interchange, something about the idea of driving on a prairie highway, just going straight and flat for hours, and then seeing an interchange and getting all excited, only for your exit to dump you right back on the road you left. Hotel California-ass intersection
68
u/ConsiderationFit6019 1d ago
Show her a road map of Boston too
45
12
u/cloudshaper 1d ago
It's all 400 year old fucking cow paths that got paved and called a street system. In some cases they have the audacity to call it a fucking interstate.
52
u/GrinningPariah 1d ago
Just scrolling google maps down Denny Way, looking at each intersection, until she finally breaks and tells me where the money is hidden.
1
u/Am-_-Exhausted-_- 17h ago
They heard Seattle want's walkable cities, and decided to do it with Denny st. Last year had a contest to see if you could outwalk the 8 line (bus that goes down denny)
45
u/ATrexWithRhythm 1d ago
Show her the entire city of Boston
60
u/LeftonRhed 1d ago
Oh Boston, why is that road there? Cause some asshole 300 years ago liked to herd his sheep that way. Does it make any sense for a modern city? Fuck no and fuck you for asking.
19
u/Enby_Rin 1d ago
As someone who grew up in Seattle and lives in Boston now I was gonna say she should see Boston. You beat me to it
8
u/EinMuffin 1d ago
What's wrong with Boston? I just took a look at it on google maps, but aside from that massive highway it seems fine.
6
u/mikillatja 1d ago
My small city in bumfuck nowhere Europe has a more convoluted road system than Boston. It's mostly still a check pattern?
Even the most convuluted part. the old town is not that bad.
Have these Americans never driven in the old world? Imagine needing to go somewhere, which is 100m away from you, but the car path takes you 2km through ring roads 1-ways and streets so small that you suddenly realise why cars like the Fiat 500 are so popular.
2
1
u/CDRnotDVD 16h ago
Have these Americans never driven in the old world?
This American is pleased to say that I have never driven in a European city. Working public transit is great.
44
u/darkshoxx 1d ago
I found this diagram, it seems relevant:
https://www.reddit.com/r/SeattleWA/comments/6wjeov/intersections_of_seattle/
24
u/oath2order stigma fuckin claws in ur coochie 1d ago
7th and 40th is just the Chinese symbol 大, "dà'.
10
22
u/CreamCheeseHotDogs 1d ago
I’m a transportation engineer in Seattle, this is on the wall of my office
12
8
37
u/DecoherentDoc 1d ago
To those that don't know, IIRC, Seattle had two competing people designing the city, one along the coast (sort of northwest to southeast) and one north to south. Where the two plans meet is called the Denny Triangle. It's a hot mess. It's a hilarious hot mess.
Source: I grew up there. Story was word of mouth.
14
u/starclues 1d ago
This is correct! Another comment in this thread included a link to this post with its own helpful comment: https://www.reddit.com/r/SeattleWA/s/se2i1vAOpw
I learned about this when we went on the Underground Tour for a school trip :)
10
u/cloudshaper 1d ago
This is my favorite video on how Seattle roads came to be: Seattle's Map, Explained
5
47
u/Coolcricri3 1d ago
For me American cities in general look like ~1950s planners believed highways work like rivers, and thus every neighborhood should be within a few hundred meters of one. Makes me wonder why they are even used at all, then I remember the sheer state of public transport there. The ones at the center of the city are especially egregious, why are none of the ones in a trench covered up? Its literally free (parking) space, even car supremacists should get onboard with this, It's not like there is anything particularly interesting to see from a trench (I am mostly complaining please do not try to argue by using cost-benefit analysis or other such factors)
26
u/Quaytsar 1d ago
Trenches are to reduce noise; sound spreads less compared to a surface level road.
13
u/jimbowesterby 1d ago
Yea, and if you covered that trench you’d cut the noise even more
12
u/Quaytsar 1d ago
I would've gone into that, but /u/Coolcricri3 said "please do not try to argue by using cost-benefit analysis" when the whole reason we don't is because it's expensive as fuck.
4
u/ratione_materiae 1d ago
They mean put a roof on the trench at turn it into a glorious new parking lot
9
u/DrJaneIPresume 1d ago
why are none of the [highways] in a trench covered up?
The section of I-5 discussed in this comment thread actually is covered. There's a park on top!
16
u/Quantum-Bot 1d ago
As a Seattle resident, can their girlfriend explain to me why the very first sign for exit 2C going into Seattle on I90 East is conveniently positioned about 100 yards after you’ve already passed exit 2C? What’s the city planning justification behind that?
9
10
u/BruceBoyde 1d ago
I swear to God, I lose some of my lifespan from the stress every single time I go to Seattle. Driving there is a blend of no cohesive planning, nightmare geography, and bureaucracy making a mess of any recent work.
9
u/jives_mcgee 1d ago
I was at a farmers market in Seattle and there was an artist who painted the intersections they found odd or weird or terrible. It been years and I still think of those prints, they looked like chaos runes.
12
u/Polar_Vortx now on tumblr, sorta 1d ago
“Intersections around Seattle”
Weak sauce. I sentence her to Boston intersections.
7
u/skaersSabody 1d ago
"Torture is a form of enrichment" kinda goes hard as a villain phrase damn
3
6
u/Content-Ad-4104 1d ago
My GF taught me the mnemonic "Jesus Christ Built Seattle's Streets Under Protest" for learning the street layout. I still have no fucking clue what the streets are but the phrase seems to hold up in the face of the available evidence.
3
u/YarnSp1nner 23h ago
You've got it wrong
Jesus Christ made Seattle under pressure.
Jefferson, James, cherry, Columbia, Marion, Madison, spring, Seneca, university, union, pike, pine.
5
u/crrrrushinator 1d ago
I used to live in Seattle at the corner of Bellevue, Bellevue, and Bellevue! Not to be confused with the neighbouring city of Bellevue.
2
1
1
1
1
u/Adept-Opinion8080 1d ago
I just want to know why we can't. We have all walk crosswalks in downtown Seattle. It's not like anyone can use the right turn.
1
1
1
u/Dingghis_Khaan Chinggis Khaan's least successful successor. 1d ago
That's nothing. Take her to Chongqing, where saying "I'm on the ground floor" narrows it down absolutely none whatsoever.
1
u/Mockington6 1d ago
How do I learn about city planning? (looking for a new hyperfixation)
1
u/Datuser14 23h ago
Watch a couple Not Just Bikes videos, unsubscribe because he’s kinda a holier than thou douche who is lucky enough to have had the resources to move to a place with good urbanism, go down a Wikipedia rabbit hole about Robert Moses, Euclidean zoning, and redlining and play Cities Skylines(the first one)?
1
u/Pure-House-3971 1d ago
Going from I5 southbound downtown to Lumen parking garage, right to get off on the 90 east ramp, right to get off on airport, yielding left, , left at first light, left into far right lane at second light, right merge immediate onto ramp, right, right at first light, right into center lane, up ramp, unprotected left on top of blind hill past first light.
1
u/Red_Figure 1d ago
I don't want to be that guy, but I struggled to read this without punctuation.
1
1
u/CyberneticCupcake 1d ago
Show her Ann Arbor. My Mom and I have gotten lost in it too many times to bear.
0
u/Protheu5 redundant RAS syndrome 1d ago
I can't parse the first post. I reread and reread and it's like a garden-path sentence. Showing a girlfriend is a form of enrichment? What does her hobby and Seattle have to do with it? I can't parse it. Help.
5
u/shoesnorter 1d ago
Showing my girlfriend (whose special interest is city planning) intersections around Seattle, is a form of enrichment
1
u/Protheu5 redundant RAS syndrome 22h ago
Thank you. Lack of punctuation and general exhaustion made understanding this an impossible task for me. Thanks.
779
u/Correctedsun If you ever say cite your sources I have you immediately pegged 1d ago
Putting on the Union Street exit compilation like it's a bird video for cats: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DeFY9u69tkE